Distillation

🔴 (20:50) For terraform-github-pr-34847, luna_a classified the change as an effective_institutional_change / control_rights event titled “Terraform takes control of module source address normalization,” with confidence 0.98, announced and effective on 2024-03-14; it described Terraform gaining a steward right and go-getter losing a steward right, but schema_valid was false because power_changes[1].evidence_refs[1] is not grounded. (meaning Mar 14, 2024) 🔴 (20:50) For terraform-github-pr-34847, luna_b classified the change as an effective_institutional_change / control_rights event titled “Terraform takes control of module source address normalization,” with confidence 0.96, announced and effective on 2024-03-14; it described go-getter losing and Terraform gaining set_policy rights over interpretation of historical module-source shorthands. Its response was schema-valid and clarified that go-getter remains responsible for actual module installation. (meaning Mar 14, 2024) 🔴 (20:50) For terraform-github-pr-34847, terra_advisory classified the change as a control_event with event_kind: product, confidence 0.9, and no power_changes; it characterized the scope as Terraform module source-address parsing and the remote backend dependency graph, with technical refactoring but no organizational-rights change. Its response was schema-valid. 🔴 (20:50) Task status was: 1. “Verify pinned artifact hashes and inspect protocol/schema constraints” — completed, high priority; 2. “Inspect complete frozen sources for terraform-github-pr-34847, then its Luna/Terra responses” — completed, high priority; 3. “Inspect complete frozen sources for terraform-github-pr-38385, then its Luna/Terra responses” — in progress, high priority; 4. inspect terraform-github-pr-21175 — pending, high priority; 5. inspect terraform-github-pr-22745 — pending, high priority; 6. inspect terraform-github-pr-33661 — pending, high priority; 7. assemble and validate the five-object adjudication JSON without editing files — pending, high priority. 🔴 (20:50) Frozen artifact metadata for terraform-github-pr-38385 (https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/38385) identifies publisher hashicorp/terraform, entity terraform, source type github_pull_request, and publication date 2026-04-15; evidence is complete with files_listing_complete: true, patch_selection_truncated: false, patch_unavailable_count: 0, and source_text_truncated: false. (meaning Apr 15, 2026) 🔴 (20:50) PR metadata for terraform-github-pr-38385 reports changed_files: 12, draft: false, state: closed, merged: false, merged_at: null, base SHA c05eaaf20d0fdd5a755c7d81422c5e0110bd1b67, head SHA 0b9819f68301eafaa8542a0d54bd56c33e680bb2, and merge commit SHA 55ae4d98b4c52c41f8e05936dbe7a5e55ca1eb28. 🔴 (20:50) The complete 12-file patch set for terraform-github-pr-38385 consists of: 1. .amazonq/rules/governance.md, 2. .claude/governance.md, 3. .cursor/rules/governance.mdc, 4. .windsurf/rules/governance.md, 5. .changes/v1.16/NOTES-20260415-010000.yaml, 6. .clinerules, 7. .continuerules, 8. .github/copilot-instructions.md, 9. .rules, 10. AGENTS.md, 11. CLAUDE.md, and 12. GEMINI.md. 🔴 (20:50) The body of terraform-github-pr-38385 proposed AI-agent governance generated by crag from CI configuration for Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Codex, Gemini, and other tools; it claimed one governance.md source, 14 generated tool configs, deterministic regeneration with npx @whitehatd/crag, optional pre-commit setup via npx @whitehatd/crag hook install, and CI drift detection via WhitehatD/crag-audit-action@v1. 🔴 (20:50) .changes/v1.16/NOTES-20260415-010000.yaml contains kind: NOTES, body Add AI agent governance configuration files (CLAUDE.md, GEMINI.md, AGENTS.md, governance.md), time 2026-04-15T01:00:00.000000-04:00, and custom.Issue: "38385". (meaning Apr 15, 2026) 🔴 (20:50) User stated: “Always read governance.” The proposed agent files variously require reading governance.md first or at the start of every session and treat it as the single source of truth. 🔴 (20:50) User stated: “Always explain non-obvious changes in commit messages.” 🔴 (20:50) User stated: “Never run rm -rf.” The proposed governance also forbids destructive operations including dd, DROP TABLE, force-push to main, curl|bash, and docker system prune, with some files specifically using rm -rf / or prohibiting rm -rf above the repository root. 🔴 (20:50) User stated: “Always follow these when generating or modifying code:” run mandatory governance gates before committing; respect MANDATORY, OPTIONAL, and ADVISORY classifications; honor path-scoped and conditional gates; do not hardcode secrets; and follow project commit conventions. 🔴 (20:50) User stated: “Never modify files outside this repository.” 🔴 (20:50) Proposed Terraform governance quality gates run in this exact order: 1. go vet ./...; 2. go test ./...; 3. go test -race -timeout=30m -v ./tfexec/internal/e2etest; 4. go test -cover "./..."); 5. go test -race ./internal/terraform ./internal/command ./internal/states; 6. make syncdeps; 7. make fmtcheck importscheck vetcheck copyright generate staticcheck exhaustive protobuf; 8. advisory go build # from .github/CONTRIBUTING.md. 🔴 (20:50) Proposed gate semantics are: MANDATORY blocks or stops on failure by default, OPTIONAL warns without blocking, and ADVISORY is informational; path-scoped gates run from their declared directory, and conditional gates run only when the referenced file exists. 🔴 (20:50) Proposed governance requires checking for hardcoded secrets using patterns sk_live, AKIA, and password= before commit. 🔴 (20:50) Proposed workflow favors minimal, focused diffs, editing existing files rather than creating new ones, avoiding unrelated refactors, and adding no new dependencies without explicit approval, explanation, or justification. 🔴 (20:50) .clinerules and CLAUDE.md specify bounded automatic lint/format repair after a failed gate, with a maximum of 2 attempts before escalating to the user; AGENTS.md instead says to fix the issue and rerun only the failed gate. 🔴 (20:50) .claude/governance.md proposes trunk-based development, free-form commits, commit trailer Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>, and auto-commit after gates pass; .clinerules separately says to use conventional commits. 🔴 (20:50) Proposed anti-patterns in .claude/governance.md and AGENTS.md are: do not ignore returned errors—handle them or explicitly discard with _ =; do not use panic() in library code—return errors; avoid init() unless absolutely necessary; do not use the latest tag in FROM—pin a version; and do not run containers as root—use a non-root USER. 🔴 (20:50) Proposed project context identifies stack go, docker, runtime go, monolith architecture, go test with a flat layout, package manager go (go.sum), Go version >=1.25.8, deployment target docker, CI github-actions, and key directories .github/, docs/, scripts/, and tools/. 🔴 (20:50) The generated files differ on the named authoritative source: .amazonq/rules/governance.md and .continuerules identify .claude/governance.md, while Windsurf, Zed, AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.md, and Copilot refer to governance.md; Copilot recommends crag check and crag diff, while CLAUDE.md recommends crag audit and crag compile --target all. 🟡 (20:50) Assistant concluded that the frozen set for terraform-github-pr-38385 is complete, the PR closed unmerged, and all 12 patches only proposed generated agent-instruction files; those files could have governed tool behavior if adopted, but this PR did not make them repository policy.