Distillation

🟡 (05:31) Assistant reported /tmp/opencode/terraform-prs-23-24.json passed the repository fragment validator with zero errors; PR 34096’s record passed adjudication $defs validation, but its fragment lacked two required envelope fields and was returned for envelope-only correction; the empty ZIP resource audit received its one permitted retry.
🔴 (05:31) /tmp/opencode/terraform-prs-23-24.json contained exact envelope keys schema_version, design_status, reviewers, and records, with schema_version: 1 and design_status: "performance_blinded_llm_assisted_source_adjudication".
🔴 (05:31) The Terraform PRs 23–24 fragment identified reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-prs-23-24, type llm, model openai/gpt-5.6-sol, role source_adjudicator, with assistance "Independent LLM source-first adjudication of the two assigned frozen records."
🔴 (05:31) terraform-github-pr-21345 was coded decision: "accept" from terra_advisory; source audit was inspected before codings and used body, pr_metadata, patch:0, patch:1, and patch:2; source text, files listing, and patch selection were untruncated/complete, with patch_unavailable_count: 0.
🔴 (05:31) PR 21345 evidence stated: "Going forward Habitat installation will require users to accept [Chef EULA](https://www.chef.io/end-user-license-agreement/)."
🔴 (05:31) PR 21345’s merged patch added required Terraform Habitat provisioner argument accept_license, rejected applicable installations when acceptance was false, and ran Habitat with HAB_LICENSE=accept; the evidence confined the effective implementation to Terraform’s Habitat provisioner and did not establish when Chef’s broader EULA policy became effective or whether other Habitat installation methods required acceptance.
🔴 (05:31) PR 21345 final coding was record_class: "effective_institutional_change", event_kind: "license", title "Terraform Habitat provisioner requires EULA acceptance", affected scope "Terraform Habitat provisioner installations", effective_on: "2019-08-05", announced_on: null, body_patch_relation: "consistent", and confidence 0.93; ambiguity stated enforcement was evidenced for Terraform’s Habitat provisioner, not all Habitat installation methods.
🔴 (05:31) PR 21345 had one effective modified license power change: actor Chef Software, target Habitat installation, scope Terraform Habitat provisioner installations, right_kind: "license"; supporting evidence included required accept_license, HAB_LICENSE=accept, and merge timestamp 2019-08-05T16:40:34Z. Its terra_advisory graph-edge revision added 0 edges and removed 0.
🔴 (05:31) terraform-github-pr-22332 was coded decision: "accept" from terra_advisory; source audit was inspected before codings and used body, pr_metadata, patch:0, patch:1, and patch:2; source text, files listing, and patch selection were untruncated/complete, with patch_unavailable_count: 0.
🔴 (05:31) PR 22332 reverted PR 21345 by removing Terraform’s Habitat accept_license schema, validation, decoding, HAB_LICENSE command, and related provisioner documentation.
🔴 (05:31) PR 22332’s sources never establish that Chef’s underlying license rights or terms changed; they establish removal only from Terraform’s Habitat provisioner and provisioner documentation, not a change to Chef’s underlying EULA or installation paths outside Terraform.
🔴 (05:31) PR 22332 final coding was record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "license", title "Revert license-acceptance requirements", affected scope "Terraform Habitat provisioner and provisioner documentation", effective_on: "2019-08-05", announced_on: null, body_patch_relation: "consistent", confidence 0.98, ambiguity null, and power_changes: []; merge evidence was "merged_at": "2019-08-05T16:44:24Z. Its terra_advisory graph-edge revision added 0 edges and removed 0.
🟡 (05:32) Assistant stated Terraform records 23–24 were fully validated and uncontaminated and that the exact corrected fragment would be retained; PR 34096 still awaited envelope-only correction, while validator edits remained blocked on active audits.
🔴 (05:34) Work status listed 11 items in order: 1. Identify the lowest-numbered open issue and recover its full acceptance criteria — completed; 2. Inspect the relevant implementation and establish a failing regression or baseline — completed; 3. Integrate and verify all 18 OpenTofu source adjudications — completed; 4. Integrate and verify completed Terraform subset C adjudications — completed; 5. Integrate and verify all 10 Valkey source adjudications — completed; 6. Integrate and verify the remaining seven Terraform source adjudications — in progress; 7. Harden frozen-input verification against adversarial provenance findings — completed; 8. Assemble the exact 40-record adjudication envelope with the gate closed for unresolved records — pending; 9. Run targeted and full verification — pending; 10. Obtain independent correctness and security reviews and address findings — pending; 11. Resolve empty or non-terminating reviewer sessions without overlapping active scopes — pending. All had priority high.
🔴 (05:34) [file-added] Added cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/fragments/terraform-prs-23-24.json.
🔴 (05:34) A 15-minute follow-up was scheduled as cma0rpca with instructions to continue issue #4 only from completed notifications; validate and integrate only schema-valid, uncontaminated Terraform fragments; wait for JSON/pin, ZIP resource retry, required-member, and active ZIP metadata follow-up before editing the shared module; then add fail-first regressions for every substantive CLI/descriptor/archive finding, fix, and verify; never poll, duplicate, or overlap; retry once after a first empty reviewer result and replace only twice-empty reviewers; retain exactly one follow-up otherwise.
🟡 (05:34) Assistant reported Terraform records 23–24 were durably integrated after strict fragment validation, bringing durable coverage to exactly 38/40; PRs 34096 and 34103 remained pending clean, schema-valid artifacts.

Distillation

Observations