Dashboard › institutional-transition-lab › Distillation
32882b9e-706a-46d8-916a-c825a742efe2["lore_tm_v1_Mx9NupqZjfzGyD47yzUGTSkj0L9H-9uPT33wmo00Cpc","lore_tm_v1_i4uDXQFtcCBLwG2dOP18ZRDE9mXzoGWWhEGUD6QYZDQ","lore_tm_v1_lP7HRVPbaxlxPKZsxzupmZh0SIVO5NdyhY_Dnug1Cl4","lore_tm_v1_iDjwV97OG5RU3jyyiZyYdVK0uJbcTVWJlw7B5DeniK8","lore_tm_v1_Scm2rk_FuztSfGMpozGE-yIhodnCRsH7zduiCRY7V84","lore_tm_v1_QbSMycHcWihwvcgAhTJ92hGSKDonaCOiJFDLEuIdK8o","lore_tm_v1_yQ-70Bmc9b61G81DBAgtEnovHJiqd1dFBLYaosZJl9k","lore_tm_v1_b-xWvMPJmp-dTmZLSvU8VMJQ8nUv9X3xfeNrCElS2Hc","lore_tm_v1_YRcSbixfyJyPMbKwkEDtcsLQE7_BzTY3YIZUgbRK-to","lore_tm_v1_UiIFjGJMJqwM_bU2l83cJU0h7CqLjtcGvexJRMSBDv4","lore_tm_v1_UfpJn74gHg_YarcJaCCsyDw-A1WE0CnnXMJXAe74pn0","lore_tm_v1_C2Go9gppMtAJHirSPZn2DNFWIRxQUrkwLU1-GA6i-S4","lore_tm_v1_QA-50Ec6bt5eVw88ICVQ5jub1NtVMuP7MY8WlWpk80g"]
valkey-github-pr-2927 Terra advisory response was schema-invalid despite coding effective_institutional_change / board_or_steering; validation error: power_changes[1].evidence_refs[0] is not grounded.valkey-github-pr-2927 ordered edge revisions were: 1. modified TSC set_membership authority under the 1/3 organization-affiliation composition limit and corrective removal/reassignment procedures; 2. modified TSC approve authority for technical major decisions via simple majority or, after a two-week period with no negative vote, explicit +2 support from at least two TSC members; 3. modified TSC approve authority for Governance Major Decisions by a 2/3 affirmative vote of the entire TSC; 4. modified TSC delegate authority over decision-making for other Valkey-organization projects through the Governance Major Decision process.valkey-github-pr-345 Luna A coding: schema-valid effective_institutional_change, event_kind=board_or_steering, announced 2024-04-21, effective 2024-04-30, body_patch_relation=patch_supersedes_body, confidence 0.99; ordered added edges were: 1. TSC set_membership over Maintainers and accordingly TSC members by no less than a 2/3 affirmative vote; 2. TSC appoint authority over a Chair; 3. TSC delegate authority over decision-making for other Valkey-organization projects; 4. TSC override authority over decisions made by other Valkey-organization projects.valkey-github-pr-345 Luna B coding: schema-valid effective_institutional_change, event_kind=board_or_steering, announced 2024-04-21, effective 2024-04-30, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.99; ordered added edges were: 1. Technical Steering Committee set_membership over TSC members by no less than a 2/3 affirmative vote; 2. Technical Steering Committee appoint authority over the Chair; 3. Technical Steering Committee set_policy authority over the governance document by no less than a 2/3 affirmative vote; 4. Technical Steering Committee delegate authority over decision-making for other Valkey-organization projects; 5. Technical Steering Committee override authority over decisions made by other Valkey-organization projects.valkey-github-pr-345 Terra coding: schema-valid effective_institutional_change, event_kind=board_or_steering, announced 2024-04-21, effective 2024-04-30, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.98; ordered added edges were: 1. TSC set_policy authority over all technical, project, approval, and policy matters for Valkey; 2. current TSC set_membership authority over Maintainers and accordingly TSC members by no less than a 2/3 affirmative vote; 3. TSC appoint authority over a Chair; 4. TSC delegate authority to maintainers responsible for other Valkey-organization projects; 5. TSC override authority over decisions made by those projects.valkey-github-pr-345 had route reasons, in order: body_patch_relation_disagreement and edge_disagreement; the model disagreement concerned whether the body was consistent with or superseded by the patch and which governance-authority edges to retain./home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/v1.2-coding-package.json: adjudication_count=35, canonical_ledger_records=0, coding_id=oss-governance-enriched-coding-v1, documents_sha256=d70f7f795847968339a645b6dbd6d4428af6bd6044de44fa2602d4c4343b0ee9, full_response_agreement_count=0, luna_a_invalid_count=5, luna_b_invalid_count=2, luna_class_agreement=0.675, luna_strict_edge_agreement=0.55, provisional_core_agreement_count=5, record_count=40, schema_version=1, terra_completed=true, and terra_invalid_count=1.abstention=4, body_patch_relation_disagreement=11, bounded_evidence=6, class_disagreement=13, edge_disagreement=18, event_field_disagreement=13, invalid_response=6, and low_confidence=5.GOVERNANCE.md diff for valkey-github-pr-2927 establishes additional details: maintainers and committers “shall” be listed in each project’s MAINTAINERS.md; an exceeded 1/3 organization-affiliation limit must be reported promptly, corrected using termination procedures, targeted for resolution within 30 days, and documented; a technical-major-decision +2 approval requires at least two explicit supporters after two weeks with no negative vote; a TSC-member author/proposer’s +1 counts toward +2; any negative vote forces simple-majority procedure; and a completed +2 approval can only be challenged through a new major-decision process rather than direct retraction.valkey-github-pr-2927 patch defines Governance Major Decisions to include: 1. adding or involuntarily removing TSC members; 2. modifying GOVERNANCE.md; 3. delegating project maintainership or governance authority; 4. creating, modifying, or removing project roles; 5. changing voting rules, TSC responsibilities, or project oversight; 6. structural TSC changes including composition limits.valkey-github-pr-2927 voting/termination changes: Governance Major Decisions require a 2/3 affirmative vote of the entire TSC; tied votes preserve the status quo; involuntary removal now proceeds through the Governance Major Decision process; resignation remains by written notice; an unreachable member remains removable by simple majority after more than six months of unresponsiveness; delegation of project decision-making is explicitly a Governance Major Decision.GOVERNANCE.md patch for valkey-github-pr-345 defines the Valkey project as all current and future repositories under the Valkey-io organization and defines maintainers as individuals with full commit access synchronized with each repository’s MAINTAINERS.md.valkey-github-pr-345 governance voting process is consensus-first; full-TSC explicit agreement is preferred but not required, consensus is judged in good faith from the dominant view and the nature of support and objections, evidence of consensus must be documented, and failed consensus proceeds to a vote.valkey-github-pr-345 rules allow any TSC member to call a vote with reasonable notice and separate discussion/voting periods; discussion may occur in person or electronically by text, voice, or video; discussion is public except for embargoed security matters and maintainer additions/removals; each voting member has one vote; at least two weeks must be allowed for voting; and ordinary decisions require a simple majority of voting members unless otherwise specified./home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/schema/governance-adjudication-v1.schema.json requires each adjudication record to contain exactly these required fields: record_id, source_url, decision, accepted_from, reviewer_ids, source_audit, rationale, evidence_limitations, unresolved_reason, claim_evidence_refs, final_coding, and graph_edge_revision; additionalProperties=false.source_url must be a GitHub URI matching ^https://github\\.com/[^\\s]+$; decision is one of accept, revise, reject, or abstain; accepted_from is one of luna_a, luna_b, terra_advisory, or null; reviewer_ids must be a nonempty unique string array; final_coding and graph_edge_revision may each be their corresponding schema object or null.body and evidence bounds files_listing_complete=null, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, and source_text_truncated=false./home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/fragments/valkey-31-33.json uses reviewer opencode-sol-valkey-issues-a1, model openai/gpt-5.6-sol, role source_adjudicator, design status performance_blinded_llm_assisted_source_adjudication, and demonstrates source-first adjudication for three frozen Valkey issue records.valkey-31-33.json demonstrates that issue-only records use body_patch_relation=body_only; publication dates can be grounded through record_metadata; accepted proposal-only rights produce no canonical graph additions; and revised/rejected model codings use accepted_from=null.valkey-31-33.json, repository placement under valkey-io was treated narrowly: valkey-github-issue-3441 supports only a proposed own edge for valkey-io over valkey-io/valkey-skills, because transfer versus recreation remained unresolved and no effective transfer was shown./home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/fragments/valkey-34-35.json uses reviewer opencode-sol-valkey-a2, model openai/gpt-5.6-sol, role source_adjudicator, and assistance description “Source-first review of two frozen Valkey records.”valkey-34-35.json establishes a relevant precedent from valkey-github-issue-4508: repository/package placement, community-maintenance language, governance documents, and standard review processes do not by themselves expressly allocate an organizational right; inferring steward power from repository placement was rejected, yielding no_event, event_kind=null, body_patch_relation=body_only, no power changes, and removal of Terra’s proposed stewardship edge.validate_adjudication_fragment() at /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/src/institution_lab/governance_adjudication.py; it validates against a fragment schema, checks reviewer data, requires document/coding/fragment records to be arrays, rejects duplicate fragment record IDs, and requires fragment IDs to be a known subset in frozen document order./tmp/opencode existed as a directory owned by byk:byk, last shown with permissions drwxr-xr-x.+2 approval path to the TSC-rule revision; and limit the licensing conclusion to retained patches while expressly recording patch-selection truncation./tmp/opencode.