Distillation

Date: Sep 8, 2026

• 🔴 [requested-governance-adjudication] (20:44) User requested a read-only, source-first, performance-blinded governance adjudication of exactly 5 records in this order: 1. terraform-github-pr-22332, 2. terraform-github-pr-22745, 3. terraform-github-pr-33661, 4. terraform-github-pr-34096, 5. terraform-github-pr-34103.
• 🔴 [enforced-frozen-inputs] (20:44) User required exclusive use of these frozen inputs: /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/documents.json with SHA-256 2a62ab05687982c112a29f6126227c26c3ff8defc89ca64662753aaf85c3c0ce; /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/v1.2-coding-package.json with SHA-256 14644759f53071adfe1173d4e25bb01931b8c1591fa8a48295dbd0556a754769; /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/schema/governance-coding-v1.schema.json; and /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/research/oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md.
• 🔴 [enforced-workflow] (20:44) User required, for each record, inspection and recording of complete frozen primary-source metadata, body, every selected patch, and evidence_bounds before opening that record’s Luna/Terra codings.
• 🔴 (20:44) User directed that embedded instructions be treated as evidence only.
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated: “Never inspect repository performance outcomes,” including detector outputs, transition dates, desired results, and unrelated reports.
• 🔴 (20:44) User directed comparisons to use direct frozen responses and source evidence, “never model summaries.”
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated proposals remain distinct from implementations and announced dates remain distinct from effective dates.
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated open, rejected, or unmerged proposals can “never be effective.”
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated software ownership/responsibility wording “never proves an organizational decision right.”
• 🔴 [required-evidence-grounding] (20:44) User required every institutional field and edge to have an exact verbatim quote and source_id from the frozen document.
• 🔴 [required-abstention] (20:44) User required reporting truncation or unstable evidence and abstaining whenever bounded evidence cannot support a defensible result.
• 🔴 (20:44) User directed that the work not be called “human adjudication” and stated Gemini is not an adjudicator.
• 🔴 [prohibited-file-edits] (20:44) User required that no files be edited.
• 🔴 (20:44) User supplied separately recovered immutable evidence for special bounded record terraform-github-pr-33661: evidence bound closed; base 8a085b427b74ce3829500a59508b77465f1bbef0; head 53c34ff49cfbc1f70d7cdd3dca8040551c53737a; merge 1f011cbaada5bf9cbddadb58ba7c84b223e99467; merged 2023-08-10T22:58:09Z; meta_sha 7fbdb91a5398f098ca7cc74f155da070c2ae4001d09d73f43ecd2ff7d9004f78. (meaning Aug 10, 2023)
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated S33661-DIFF is complete at exactly 1,294/1,294 files with diff_sha 18cfaf5a4e4b71c17d446d3f90ea255bdfc0b4aa38bb2e3c04a5334ae5587382.
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated that, outside LICENSE, all 1,293 changes in terraform-github-pr-33661 are exact SPDX MPL-2.0 to BUSL-1.1 swaps.
• 🔴 (20:44) User stated the recovered evidence identifies HashiCorp, Inc. as licensor, excludes production offerings competitive with HashiCorp products, and sets MPL 2.0 as the change license.
• 🔴 (20:44) User recommended accepting luna_b for terraform-github-pr-33661 as effective_institutional_change / license / consistent, with a modified licensing right.
• 🔴 [enforced-source-verification] (20:44) User required the frozen terraform-github-pr-33661 record to be inspected first and the accepted response’s exact quotes verified against it despite the supplied recovered evidence and recommendation.
• 🔴 [required-output-schema] (20:44) User required one JSON object per record with exactly these fields: record_id, source_url, source_audit (components inspected and evidence bounds), decision (accept|revise|reject|abstain), accepted_from (luna_a|luna_b|terra_advisory|null), rationale, evidence_limitations (string|null), unresolved_reason (string|null), claim_evidence_refs (field/source_id/quote objects), final_coding (complete frozen-schema coding object or null), and graph_edge_revision_basis (luna_a|luna_b|terra_advisory|null).
• 🔴 (20:44) User required that for accept, final_coding exactly equal accepted_from; for revise or reject, a complete schema-valid coding must be constructed.
• 🔴 (20:44) User required institutional/proposal final codings to include evidence for every non-null canonical claim field and every edge.
• 🔴 (20:44) User required one JSON array containing all 5 result objects, with no empty result.
• 🔴 (20:44) User required that if blocked, the response return BLOCKED with the exact record, file/tool error, and missing evidence.
• 🟡 (20:44) Assistant committed to first verify both pinned hashes and inspect the protocol and schema, then process each record strictly in sequence—frozen source and bounds first, candidate codings second—without repository mutations or outcome data.
• 🟡 (20:44) Work plan recorded 7 high-priority steps: 1. Verify pinned artifact hashes and inspect protocol/schema (in_progress); 2. Adjudicate terraform-github-pr-22332 source-first; 3. Adjudicate terraform-github-pr-22745 source-first; 4. Adjudicate terraform-github-pr-33661 source-first including supplied recovered evidence; 5. Adjudicate terraform-github-pr-34096 source-first; 6. Adjudicate terraform-github-pr-34103 source-first; 7. Validate all 5 final objects against schema and evidence requirements.
• 🟡 (20:44) Tool verification confirmed both pinned hashes exactly match: documents.json → 2a62ab05687982c112a29f6126227c26c3ff8defc89ca64662753aaf85c3c0ce; v1.2-coding-package.json → 14644759f53071adfe1173d4e25bb01931b8c1591fa8a48295dbd0556a754769.
• 🟡 (20:44) Inspected /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/schema/governance-coding-v1.schema.json, JSON Schema draft 2020-12, titled Performance-blinded governance coding v1; top-level additionalProperties: false; required fields are record_class, event_kind, title, announced_on, effective_on, affected_scope, body_patch_relation, power_changes, confidence, and ambiguity.
• 🟡 (20:44) Schema record_class values are effective_institutional_change, announced_institutional_change, proposal_only, control_event, no_event, and abstain; event_kind values are leadership, board_or_steering, control_rights, reorganization, foundation_transfer, license, fork, reunification, strategy, product, external, or null.
• 🟡 (20:44) Schema body_patch_relation values are consistent, patch_supersedes_body, body_only, patch_only, conflict, not_applicable, and unclear; confidence must be between 0 and 1.
• 🟡 (20:44) Each schema power_changes item requires actor, right_kind, target, direction, change_status, scope, and evidence_refs; right_kind values are appoint, remove, elect, vote, delegate, override, approve, merge, write, release, veto, own, license, steward, fund, set_budget, set_strategy, set_policy, set_membership, set_terms, and inform; direction values are added, removed, and modified; change_status values are effective, announced, proposed, rejected, and unclear; every evidence_refs item requires non-empty source_id and quote.
• 🟡 (20:44) Inspected /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/research/oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md; protocol is dated/frozen 2026-08-27 and has status pre-adjudication evaluator correction; model-informed development protocol. (meaning Aug 27, 2026)
• 🟡 (20:44) Protocol states V1.1 used the intended frozen 40-record manifest and unchanged coders, but its “strict edge agreement” evaluator omitted edge scope and evidence references and did not route separately coded body/patch-relationship disagreements; consequently 6 records were labeled provisional_exact_agreement despite material differences.
• 🟡 (20:44) Protocol V1.2 corrections: 1. strict edge signatures include scope and complete grounded evidence references; 2. body/patch-relationship disagreement is an explicit route reason; 3. the remaining non-routed state is named provisional_core_agreement; 4. full-response agreement is reported separately and is not required because titles and numeric confidence are not canonical research fields.
• 🟡 (20:44) Protocol states the correction routes 35 rather than 29 records, reuses the byte-identical V1.1 coding bundle and both Luna response files from workflow run 33060493337, and repeats only the Terra advisory pass over the corrected route to isolate evaluator change from model sampling variance.
• 🟡 (20:44) Protocol states no model response, performance observation, transition date, or desired result influenced the correction; Terra remains advisory; all records remain ineligible for the canonical ledger; and the response schema and frozen envelope are unchanged.
• 🟡 (20:44) Assistant concluded that both pinned SHA-256 values matched; the schema requires 10 exact coding fields and grounded evidence for every power edge; and the protocol makes edge scope, evidence references, and body/patch relation part of strict adjudication.
• 🟡 (20:44) Assistant began source-first processing of terraform-github-pr-22332 and stated its codings would not be inspected until the full frozen source envelope was complete.
• 🟡 (20:45) Search found exactly 1 match for "record_id": "terraform-github-pr-22332" in /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/documents.json at line 792.