Dashboard › institutional-transition-lab › Distillation
8b3de5b1-6641-4032-ba71-a26612bc1a69["lore_tm_v1_c8FBBcMy0l9m2shpZqggcATEHDw4dEsxZdIqhLQnbmA","lore_tm_v1_vavlpm3xryyuF-gs4Q5Aw-jG1L-JfYIqMjmf59mtPNQ","lore_tm_v1_imYSpmD7guv8ByPUMHc-80neSteNDVjELbP6xnc3wic","lore_tm_v1_yc022Xwhuokw25e_mGGemfEeBWo5LMbCxDUdfUatpFw","lore_tm_v1_N_nt0DVjx5knF_Wxim-tfM5mHZylHTrGy0kkXv8MN3g","lore_tm_v1_DtWLflhoVaoEaysmMJm3Jb2vuBzdOLJOGpkkvXCOh-4","lore_tm_v1_Qlkt62jS3Iuw0s_VZPZWVc8cpnF8WwWelpnRcyvDud8"]
/tmp/opencode and run validate_adjudication_fragment against the pinned frozen inputs./home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/v1.2-coding-package.json and /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/documents.json, in this order: 1. valkey-github-issue-4509; 2. valkey-github-pr-1390; 3. valkey-github-pr-1788; 4. valkey-github-pr-2927; 5. valkey-github-pr-345.valkey-github-pr-1390: source_type=github_pull_request, URL https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/pull/1390, publisher valkey-io/valkey, published_on=2024-12-04; evidence bounds are files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, and source_text_truncated=false.valkey-github-pr-1390 body says two more committers were added while corporate-interest balance motivated explicitly separating TSC members from people with only write permissions; it also says the new people with commit permissions were added.valkey-github-pr-1390 metadata: base_sha=105509cdad1e667cd15ad751bf8b918d9ca1ca06, head_sha=e4f28d6293edd97399912e0e5f66405b97dd8eb5, merge_commit_sha=4f61034934cf165163ef272e5795bccadc288b09, changed_files=2, draft=false, merged=true, merged_at=2024-12-09T20:28:17Z, and state=closed.valkey-github-pr-1390 patch GOVERNANCE.md (source_id=patch:0) replaced the old definition equating maintainers with full commit access by defining committers as people with write access to repository code, maintainers as people with full repository access who own its governance, and requiring both groups to be listed in the repository’s MAINTAINERS.md.valkey-github-pr-1390 patch MAINTAINERS.md (source_id=patch:1) added a “Current Committers” section listing Harkrishn Patro (hpatro, Amazon) and Ran Shidlansik (ranshid, Amazon), and renamed “Former Maintainers” to “Former Maintainers and Committers.”valkey-github-pr-1390, Luna A coded effective_institutional_change, event_kind=control_rights, announced 2024-12-04, effective 2024-12-09, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.97; edges added effective write rights for Harkrishn Patro and Ran Shidlansik over code in Valkey project repositories, plus an effective own right for Maintainers over governance.valkey-github-pr-1390, Luna B coded effective_institutional_change, event_kind=control_rights, announced 2024-12-04, effective 2024-12-09, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.98; it likewise added write edges for Harkrishn Patro and Ran Shidlansik, but represented Maintainers’ governance authority as right_kind=set_policy rather than own.valkey-github-pr-1390, Terra coded effective_institutional_change, event_kind=control_rights, announced 2024-12-04, effective 2024-12-09, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.88; it added write edges for Harkrishn Patro and Ran Shidlansik and an own edge for Maintainers over repository governance. Terra’s ambiguity note said the patch distinguishes committers from maintainers but does not explicitly identify any existing governance rights removed from other people.valkey-github-pr-1390 had canonical_ledger_eligible=false, full_response_agreement=false, provisional_core_agreement=false, and route reason edge_disagreement; the principal edge disagreement was Maintainers’ governance right represented as own versus set_policy.valkey-github-pr-1788: source_type=github_pull_request, URL https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/pull/1788, publisher valkey-io/valkey, published_on=2025-02-27; evidence bounds are files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=true, patch_unavailable_count=0, and source_text_truncated=false.valkey-github-pr-1788 body describes making Valkey file licenses consistent, conservatively adding the trademark only where a material file change was judged to have occurred, resolving issue #1692, and referring to PR #1787 for licensing documentation.valkey-github-pr-1788 metadata: base_sha=1ad0c4feafb149a6f03627de03f4f810801ab875, head_sha=461b170f84d76594cddef4674733f5f815945dee, merge_commit_sha=089b830479f4984e77e570560f85e37212879740, changed_files=31, draft=false, merged=true, merged_at=2025-02-27T18:38:26Z, and state=closed.valkey-github-pr-1788 patches include: COPYING adding SPDX-License-Identifier: BSD-3-Clause; deps/fast_float_c_interface/fast_float_strtod.cpp, src/cluster_slot_stats.c, src/io_threads.c, and src/memory_prefetch.c normalizing “Copyright (c) Valkey Contributors” and BSD-3-Clause; src/allocator_defrag.c, src/asciilogo.h, src/blocked.c, src/cluster.c, src/cluster_legacy.c, src/commandlog.c, src/defrag.c, src/dict.c, src/eval.c, src/expire.c, src/functions.c, src/hyperloglog.c, src/module.c, and src/rdb.c adding, moving, or standardizing Valkey copyright/SPDX blocks; and src/lua/engine_lua.c normalizing the copyright wording.valkey-github-pr-1788, Luna A coded control_event, event_kind=license, affected scope “Valkey files,” announced and effective 2025-02-27, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.91, and no power changes; its ambiguity note said the retained patches demonstrate license-header standardization rather than organizational-rights change, while omitted changes cannot be assessed.valkey-github-pr-1788, Luna B coded abstain, event_kind=license, announced 2025-02-27, no effective date, body_patch_relation=unclear, confidence 0.55, and no power changes; it reasoned that truncated patch selection leaves open whether omitted changes contain a substantive licensing-rights change.valkey-github-pr-1788, Terra coded abstain, event_kind=license, announced 2025-02-27, no effective date, body_patch_relation=unclear, confidence 0.38, and no power changes; Terra said the merged PR and supplied excerpts do not establish whether terms or associated rights materially changed rather than merely being standardized or clarified.valkey-github-pr-1788 had canonical_ledger_eligible=false, full_response_agreement=false, provisional_core_agreement=false, and route reasons, in order: abstention, body_patch_relation_disagreement, bounded_evidence, class_disagreement, event_field_disagreement, and low_confidence.valkey-github-pr-2927: source_type=github_pull_request, URL https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/pull/2927, publisher valkey-io/valkey, published_on=2025-12-11; evidence bounds are files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, and source_text_truncated=false.valkey-github-pr-2927 body proposes four governance changes: 1. a +2 mechanism for technical major decisions; 2. simple-majority voting for non-technical decisions; 3. a 1/3 organization limit on TSC membership; 4. treating delegation and governance updates as non-technical decisions.valkey-github-pr-2927 metadata: base_sha=5940dbfb0b601dfc565ca7f349a3a62f67d7e5ed, head_sha=8d92a6e1392df217d841b869f581aa0c49542cb2, merge_commit_sha=cd6faaa726791447f7adc196b6c77cc20658112d, changed_files=1, draft=false, merged=true, merged_at=2025-12-12T16:53:50Z, and state=closed.valkey-github-pr-2927 retained GOVERNANCE.md patch requires no more than one third (1/3) of TSC members to be employees, contractors, or representatives of the same organization or affiliates; defines organization broadly to include companies, corporations, universities, research institutes, non-profits, governmental institutions, subsidiaries, and affiliates; requires prompt notice and corrective action if the limit is exceeded; and allows removal or reassignment under the termination procedures.valkey-github-pr-2927, Luna A coded effective_institutional_change, event_kind=control_rights, announced 2025-12-11, effective 2025-12-12, body_patch_relation=patch_supersedes_body, confidence 0.96; effective modified edges were: 1. TSC approval of technical major decisions by simple majority; 2. TSC approval of governance major decisions by a 2/3 affirmative vote of the entire TSC; 3. TSC set_membership authority constrained by the 1/3 organization-affiliation composition rule; 4. TSC removal of members through the Governance Major Decision process; 5. TSC approval of delegation of project decision-making as a Governance Major Decision.valkey-github-pr-2927 ambiguity note said the body calls for simple-majority voting on non-technical decisions, whereas the merged patch imposes a 2/3 threshold on governance major decisions; the merged patch was treated as controlling.valkey-github-pr-2927, Luna B coded effective_institutional_change, event_kind=board_or_steering, announced 2025-12-11, effective 2025-12-12, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence 0.98; its ordered edges were: 1. modified TSC simple-majority approval for technical major decisions; 2. added fallback approval after a two-week voting period through explicit +2 support from at least two TSC members when no member voted against; 3. added 2/3-of-entire-TSC approval for governance major decisions; 4. modified involuntary-removal authority through the Governance Major Decision process.valkey-github-pr-2927, Terra coded effective_institutional_change, event_kind=board_or_steering, announced 2025-12-11, effective 2025-12-12, body_patch_relation=patch_supersedes_body, confidence 0.92; Terra’s ambiguity note said the body labels governance updates “non-technical decisions,” while the merged implementing patch classifies them as Governance Major Decisions.valkey-github-pr-2927 had canonical_ledger_eligible=false, full_response_agreement=false, provisional_core_agreement=false, and route reasons, in order: body_patch_relation_disagreement, edge_disagreement, and event_field_disagreement.valkey-github-pr-345: source_type=github_pull_request, URL https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/pull/345, publisher valkey-io/valkey, published_on=2024-04-21; evidence bounds are files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, and source_text_truncated=false.valkey-github-pr-345 body describes the initial governance PR defining permissions for the main Valkey project and responsibilities for sub-projects.valkey-github-pr-345 metadata: base_sha=4693aa258e993ebde96f68f608224884e5c8317d, head_sha=8cb7eae5919fe42da841aec43df0b5f5b58e7f37, merge_commit_sha=b283c6b508792892d76b9a4911e3086e37518748, changed_files=3, draft=false, merged=true, merged_at=2024-04-30T21:57:21Z, and state=closed.valkey-github-pr-345 added GOVERNANCE.md, establishing a TSC composed of Valkey-repository maintainers; TSC oversight of technical, project, approval, and policy matters; maintainer/TSC additions or removals by at least a 2/3 affirmative vote; TSC appointment and replacement of its Chair; governance-document amendment by at least a 2/3 affirmative vote; discretionary addition or removal of non-main-repository maintainers and maintainers from other Valkey repositories; consensus-first decision-making; and documented evidence of consensus.valkey-github-pr-345 added a “Project governance” section to CONTRIBUTING.md linking TSC responsibilities to GOVERNANCE.md.valkey-github-pr-345 added MAINTAINERS.md with six current maintainers, alphabetically by GitHub ID: 1. Zhu Binbin (enjoy-binbin, Tencent); 2. Wen Hui (hwware, Huawei); 3. Madelyn Olson (madolson, Amazon); 4. Ping Xie (pingxie, Google); 5. Zhao Zhao (soloestoy, Alibaba); 6. Viktor Söderqvist (zuiderkwast, Ericsson).valkey-github-issue-4509, Luna A produced a schema-invalid proposal_only/control_rights response with confidence 0.98, proposing a steward edge for valkey-io over repository hosting and long-term maintenance; its quoted evidence was rejected as ungrounded (power_changes[0].evidence_refs[0] is not grounded).valkey-github-issue-4509, Luna B produced a schema-valid proposal_only/control_rights response with confidence 0.98, proposing a steward edge for valkey-io over the n8n-nodes-valkey repository, grounded in the repository-creation and official-endorsement/maintenance language.valkey-github-issue-4509, Terra produced a schema-valid no_event/product response with confidence 0.98, no power changes, and the ambiguity note that the issue proposes a product repository and package but demonstrates no organizational-rights change.valkey-github-issue-4509 had canonical_ledger_eligible=false, full_response_agreement=false, provisional_core_agreement=false, and route reasons, in order: class_disagreement, edge_disagreement, and invalid_response.