Distillation

🔴 (09:19) Preflight for cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json found exactly 12 fragments, 12 reviewers, and 40 records; fragment decisions were abstain: 4, accept: 25, reject: 3, and revise: 8. 🔴 (09:19) The four abstentions were opentofu-github-pr-2830, opentofu-github-pr-2953, opentofu-github-pr-2959, and valkey-github-issue-4276. 🔴 (09:19) Preflight checks returned current_reviewers_equal=True, current_records_equal_for_existing=True, and current_record_prefix_in_frozen_order=True. 🔴 (09:19) The 25 missing canonical records, in frozen order, were: 1. opentofu-github-pr-727; 2. opentofu-github-pr-823; 3. opentofu-github-pr-990; 4. terraform-github-issue-22468; 5. terraform-github-issue-34139; 6. terraform-github-issue-35563; 7. terraform-github-pr-21175; 8. terraform-github-pr-21345; 9. terraform-github-pr-22332; 10. terraform-github-pr-22745; 11. terraform-github-pr-33661; 12. terraform-github-pr-34096; 13. terraform-github-pr-34103; 14. terraform-github-pr-34847; 15. terraform-github-pr-38385; 16. valkey-github-issue-2961; 17. valkey-github-issue-3289; 18. valkey-github-issue-3441; 19. valkey-github-issue-4276; 20. valkey-github-issue-4508; 21. valkey-github-issue-4509; 22. valkey-github-pr-1390; 23. valkey-github-pr-1788; 24. valkey-github-pr-2927; 25. valkey-github-pr-345. 🔴 (09:21) Updated cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json by appending adjudications for opentofu-github-pr-727, opentofu-github-pr-823, and opentofu-github-pr-990; the patch applied successfully. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-727 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-opentofu-b; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0, with complete file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-727’s sole patch adds # SPDX-License-Identifier: MPL-2.0 to .github/scripts/compare-release-versions.sh; this documents licensing metadata but does not prove a new license grant, copyright transfer, or change in organizational licensing power. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-727 final coding is record_class: "no_event", event_kind: null, title "Add MPL-2.0 license identifier to compare-release-versions script", announced_on: null, effective_on: null, affected_scope: ".github/scripts/compare-release-versions.sh", body_patch_relation: "consistent", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.99, and ambiguity: null; graph revision basis is terra_advisory with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-823 was accepted from luna_a by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-opentofu-b; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0, with complete file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-823 records a unanimous TSC choice of the Homebrew-like artifact-resolution registry RFC, a decision not to pursue a user-facing registry design yet, and a founders’ arrangement to hire core-team members through pledging-company payroll rather than direct foundation payroll; these are strategy decisions and staffing facts, not changes in organizational rights. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-823’s sole-file patch supplies no downstream registry implementation and does not define a funding or appointment right. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-823 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "strategy", title "TSC selects RFC for a registry solution", announced_on: "2023-11-05", effective_on: null, affected_scope: "OpenTofu registry solution and core team staffing", body_patch_relation: "patch_only", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.94, and ambiguity: null; graph revision basis is luna_a with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-990 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-opentofu-b; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0, with complete file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-990 records a unanimous TSC product decision to change the default registry namespace to opentofu; the merged summary neither implements the change nor alters the TSC’s underlying authority. 🔴 (09:21) opentofu-github-pr-990 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "product", title "TSC decision to change the default registry namespace to opentofu", announced_on: "2023-12-10", effective_on: null, affected_scope: "OpenTofu default registry namespace", body_patch_relation: "consistent", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.91, and ambiguity "The merged patch records a TSC decision, but does not implement or otherwise show the registry namespace change taking effect."; graph revision basis is terra_advisory with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:22) Updated cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json by appending adjudications for terraform-github-issue-22468, terraform-github-issue-34139, and terraform-github-issue-35563; the patch applied successfully. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-22468 was accepted from luna_a by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-issues-19-21; only the complete body was inspected, with files_listing_complete: null, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-22468 asks for stricter -target behavior that can refuse changes outside the requested scope; it neither announces nor implements an institutional, organizational, licensing, strategy, or control-right change. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-22468 final coding is record_class: "no_event", all event/title/date/scope fields null, body_patch_relation: "not_applicable", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.96, and ambiguity: null; the frozen envelope has no comments, issue-state history, implementation patch, or later-resolution evidence, and graph revision basis is luna_a. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-34139 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-issues-19-21; only the complete body was inspected, with files_listing_complete: null, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-34139 reports an Azure access-package deployment failure, AccessPackageAssignmentPolicyClient.BaseClient.Get(): unexpected status 403, during policy association and asks for troubleshooting; it establishes no OSS institutional or product-control change. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-34139 final coding is record_class: "no_event", event_kind: null, title "Azure access package association", null dates and scope, body_patch_relation: "not_applicable", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.99, and ambiguity: null; the frozen envelope has no comments, issue-state history, patch, or later-resolution evidence, and graph revision basis is terra_advisory. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-35563 was accepted from luna_a by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-issues-19-21; only the complete body was inspected, with files_listing_complete: null, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-35563 reports Terraform crashing during terraform init on Azure Container Apps for Terraform versions below 0.15.0; it documents a technical defect, not an institutional, organizational, licensing, strategy, or control-right change. 🔴 (09:22) terraform-github-issue-35563 final coding is record_class: "no_event", event_kind: null, title "Terraform crashes on Azure Container Apps", null dates and scope, body_patch_relation: "not_applicable", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.99, and ambiguity: null; the frozen envelope has no comments, issue-state history, patch, or later-resolution evidence, and graph revision basis is luna_a. 🔴 (09:25) Updated cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json by appending adjudications for terraform-github-pr-21175, terraform-github-pr-21345, and terraform-github-pr-22332; the patch applied successfully. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21175 was revised by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-c; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0, with complete file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21175’s merged guide patch states, "All Terraform providers are required to contain a MPL-2.0 open source license."; this is a license-related guide-policy control event, but it does not identify a licensor or licensee, grant or transfer a license, establish ownership, add an organizational right, or demonstrate enforcement beyond the guide. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21175 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "license", title "MPL-2.0 licensing requirement added to the Terraform provider development guide", announced_on: "2019-05-01", effective_on: "2019-05-02", affected_scope: "Terraform provider development guide requirements", body_patch_relation: "consistent", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.94, and ambiguity that the frozen evidence does not identify a licensor/licensee, grant/transfer, or enforcement beyond the guide. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21175 graph revision uses basis: "luna_a" and removes Luna A’s candidate effective license edge from actor Terraform to target All Terraform providers, scoped to Terraform provider development; no edge is added. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21345 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-prs-23-24; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0–patch:2, with complete file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21345 states: "Going forward Habitat installation will require users to accept [Chef EULA](https://www.chef.io/end-user-license-agreement/)." 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21345’s merged implementation makes accept_license a required Terraform Habitat provisioner argument, rejects applicable installations when acceptance is false, and runs Habitat with HAB_LICENSE=accept. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21345 evidence establishes enforcement only in Terraform’s Habitat provisioner and does not cover every Habitat installation method or establish when Chef’s broader EULA policy became effective. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21345 final coding is record_class: "effective_institutional_change", event_kind: "license", title "Terraform Habitat provisioner requires EULA acceptance", announced_on: null, effective_on: "2019-08-05", affected_scope: "Terraform Habitat provisioner installations", body_patch_relation: "consistent", confidence: 0.93, and ambiguity that enforcement is evidenced for Terraform’s provisioner rather than all Habitat installation methods. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-21345 final power_changes contains one effective modified license relation: actor Chef Software, target Habitat installation, scope Terraform Habitat provisioner installations; graph revision basis is terra_advisory with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-22332 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-prs-23-24; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0–patch:2, with complete file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-22332’s merged patch reverts terraform-github-pr-21345 by removing the Habitat accept_license schema, validation and decoding, the HAB_LICENSE=accept command, and related provisioner documentation. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-22332 sources establish a technical reversion but “never establish that Chef's underlying license rights or terms changed,” and do not establish changes to Chef’s EULA or installation paths outside Terraform. 🔴 (09:25) terraform-github-pr-22332 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "license", title "Revert license-acceptance requirements", announced_on: null, effective_on: "2019-08-05", affected_scope: "Terraform Habitat provisioner and provisioner documentation", body_patch_relation: "consistent", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.98, and ambiguity: null; graph revision basis is terra_advisory with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:26) Updated cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json by appending adjudications for terraform-github-pr-22745 and terraform-github-pr-33661; the patch applied successfully at 09:27. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-22745 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-c; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0–patch:2, with a complete four-file listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-22745 states: "Going forward Habitat installation will require users to accept Chef EULA." 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-22745’s merged Terraform implementation requires EULA acceptance for affected Habitat provisioner installations, rejects configuration when acceptance is absent, and adds the required accept_license argument. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-22745 proves Terraform-side enforcement from its merge on 2019-09-09, but “never proves when Chef Software's underlying EULA policy became effective.” 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-22745 final coding is record_class: "effective_institutional_change", event_kind: "license", title "Require Chef EULA acceptance for Habitat provisioning", announced_on: "2019-09-09", effective_on: "2019-09-09", affected_scope: "Terraform Habitat provisioner installations", body_patch_relation: "consistent", confidence: 0.95, and ambiguity that the effective date of Chef Software’s underlying EULA change is not established. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-22745 final power_changes contains one effective modified license relation: actor users, target Habitat installation, scope Habitat installation through the Terraform Habitat provisioner; graph revision basis is terra_advisory with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-33661 was accepted from luna_b by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-c; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0–patch:19, with complete file listing, patch_selection_truncated: true, zero unavailable patches, and untruncated source text. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-33661’s merged LICENSE patch replaces Mozilla Public License 2.0 with Business Source License 1.1, names HashiCorp, Inc. as Licensor, and names MPL 2.0 as the Change License; this modifies licensing rights for the Terraform Licensed Work without implying an ownership transfer. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-33661 covers the complete LICENSE replacement and 19 selected SPDX-header patches from a 1,294-file PR; because the patch selection is truncated, it does not support claiming that every repository header changed, and no supplemental diff was used. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-33661 final coding is record_class: "effective_institutional_change", event_kind: "license", title "Terraform license changed from MPL 2.0 to Business Source License 1.1", announced_on: "2023-08-10", effective_on: "2023-08-10", affected_scope: "Terraform Licensed Work", body_patch_relation: "consistent", confidence: 0.98, and ambiguity that selection is truncated although the LICENSE patch directly proves the change. 🔴 (09:26) terraform-github-pr-33661 final power_changes contains one effective modified license relation: actor HashiCorp, Inc., target you, scope The Licensed Work; graph revision basis is luna_b with no additions or removals. 🔴 (09:28) Updated cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json by appending adjudications for terraform-github-pr-34096 and terraform-github-pr-34103; the patch applied successfully. 🔴 (09:28) terraform-github-pr-34096 was revised by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-pr-34096-clean; source audit inspected only body and pr_metadata, with complete files listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches, despite metadata reporting two changed files. 🔴 (09:28) terraform-github-pr-34096 describes updating HCL to v2.19.0, including an optional dynblock.Expand hook allowing applications to inspect and veto for_each values; this is an effective product control event, not an institutional-authority change. 🔴 (09:28) terraform-github-pr-34096 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "product", title "Update HCL to v2.19.0", announced_on: null, effective_on: "2023-10-17", affected_scope: "HCL v2.19.0", body_patch_relation: "body_only", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.98, and ambiguity that the envelope publication date is unsupported by source-ID-bearing text and no patches are supplied for the two changed files; graph revision basis is luna_a. 🔴 (09:28) terraform-github-pr-34103 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-pr-34103-clean-v2; source audit inspected only body and pr_metadata, with complete files listing, no truncation, and zero unavailable patches, despite metadata reporting two changed files. 🔴 (09:28) terraform-github-pr-34103 describes and merges a backport of HCL v2.19.0 into Terraform v1.6, including an enhancement and bug fixes; it is a product control event rather than a change in institutional authority. 🔴 (09:28) terraform-github-pr-34103 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "product", title "Backport HCL v2.19.0 into v1.6", announced_on: "2023-10-17", effective_on: "2023-10-17", affected_scope: "Terraform v1.6", body_patch_relation: "body_only", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.87, and ambiguity that no implementing patch content is supplied; graph revision basis is terra_advisory. 🔴 (09:30) Updated cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/adjudication.json by appending adjudications for terraform-github-pr-34847 and terraform-github-pr-38385; the patch applied successfully. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-34847 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-c; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0–patch:15, with complete file listing, patch_selection_truncated: true, zero unavailable patches, and untruncated source text. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-34847 describes source-address parsing, package movement, tests, Terraform-owned normalization of historical module-source shorthands, and remote-backend dependency pruning; its ownership/control wording concerns software responsibility and compatibility behavior, “never organizational authority.” 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-34847 covers selected patches from an 86-file PR, and patch:15 ends mid-hunk; evidence supports only the scoped source-address normalization and dependency-pruning classification, not every changed file or wider repository conclusions, and no supplemental diff was used. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-34847 final coding is record_class: "control_event", event_kind: "product", title "Terraform source-address normalization and dependency pruning", announced_on: "2024-03-14", effective_on: "2024-03-14", affected_scope: "Terraform module source-address parsing and remote backend dependency graph", body_patch_relation: "consistent", empty power_changes, confidence: 0.9, and ambiguity reflecting the truncated patch selection; graph revision basis is terra_advisory. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-38385 was accepted from terra_advisory by reviewer opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-c; source audit inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0–patch:11, covering all 12 changed files with no unavailable or truncated patch. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-38385 proposes repository governance instructions allowing named AI coding tools—Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Codex, and Gemini—to auto-commit after quality gates pass; the PR is closed and unmerged, so the delegation was proposed but never implemented or adopted. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-38385 final coding is record_class: "proposal_only", event_kind: "control_rights", title "Add AI agent governance", announced_on: "2026-04-15", effective_on: null, affected_scope: "terraform repository", body_patch_relation: "consistent", confidence: 0.82, and ambiguity that the proposal does not establish implementation or adoption. 🔴 (09:30) terraform-github-pr-38385 final power_changes contains one proposed added delegate relation: actor terraform, target AI coding tools (Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Codex, Gemini), scope autonomous commits in the terraform repository after quality gates pass; graph revision basis is terra_advisory with no additions or removals.