Dashboard › institutional-transition-lab › Distillation
ba0edeee-bbc0-413b-8a42-eb48beb20722["lore_tm_v1_xtnYiFoWHFUyzWyxMeJOMArkOIUvkCVDfEmLktEgDxE","lore_tm_v1_ns92wfMf0Ip9HVn2qx6Re3Ck5CoVGkHbYUs2sjCW7H8","lore_tm_v1_QljGDrlhDkMzsX5rDMWk1raw0aWFJ9ezXaM7Y4dNuU8","lore_tm_v1_hYONVMV-ptmE21Y-qeo7dZ-2v6P-fz6hHcrMqxzlxOo","lore_tm_v1_g16zRFEja_0ca2x310Fa9eDStfnIF9i2cIM679ZvIPM","lore_tm_v1_Fgc00IeFj0BdVc-AqUI2crzHJUkZG0EfXK4osIU3b_w"]
/home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/src/institution_lab/governance_adjudication.py lines 182–203, decisions accept, revise, and reject require dictionary-valued final_coding that passes validate_response(); abstain requires final_coding=null and a nonempty unresolved_reason; resolved decisions require unresolved_reason=null; and reject must resolve to a class outside INSTITUTIONAL_CLASSES.governance_adjudication.py lines 205–218, claim_evidence_refs must be an array; every reference is checked by _evidence_errors() against _source_index(document); institutional claims require at least one evidence reference; and each non-null field in CLAIM_FIELDS is treated as ungrounded when references are absent.governance_adjudication.py lines 220–235, abstain requires graph_edge_revision=null; resolved decisions require a dictionary-valued revision; basis must be one of luna_a, luna_b, terra_advisory, or None; and added/removed must exactly equal the deterministic result of graph_edge_diff(baseline, final_coding).governance_adjudication.py lines 239–277, validate_adjudication() requires transition_dates_excluded=true and outcome_data_used=false; compares every sorted REQUIRED_INPUT_PINS entry with verified_pins; verifies inputs.documents_sha256 and coding_package.summary.documents_sha256 against canonical_sha256(documents); requires a nonempty reviewer array; validates every reviewer; and rejects duplicate reviewer_id values.records, schema_version, and summary; each record exposes canonical_ledger_eligible, full_response_agreement, luna_a, luna_b, provisional_core_agreement, record_id, route_reasons, source_url, and terra_advisory.opentofu-github-pr-2830: luna_a coded effective_institutional_change/control_rights with 5 added effective edges—TSC set_strategy, TSC approve Contributor→Committer, TSC remove Committer, TSC elect TSC Chair, and LF Projects own Project Trademarks; luna_b coded effective_institutional_change/board_or_steering with 5 added effective edges—TSC approve, remove, appoint representatives, delegate authority to project maintainers, and override maintainer decisions; terra_advisory coded effective_institutional_change/board_or_steering with 3 added effective edges—TSC approve, remove, and override. Their confidence values were respectively 0.98, 0.96, and 0.89.opentofu-github-pr-2953: luna_a and luna_b both returned record_class="abstain", event_kind="reorganization", and no power edges because the visible change relocated governance documentation while a 43-file truncated patch left possible omissions; terra_advisory likewise abstained with no event kind or effective date because no organizational-rights change was established. Confidence values were 0.70, 0.58, and 0.42.terraform-github-pr-33661: all 3 classified the merged MPL 2.0→Business Source License 1.1 replacement as an effective_institutional_change/license with one modified effective licensing edge; luna_a and luna_b treated HashiCorp, Inc. as actor, while terra_advisory treated “You” as actor. Confidence values were 0.99, 0.98, and 0.94.terraform-github-pr-34847: luna_a coded effective transfer of module-source normalization stewardship from go-getter to Terraform; luna_b coded effective transfer of policy-setting over historical module-address shorthand interpretation from go-getter to Terraform; terra_advisory coded a non-institutional control_event/product with no power edges. Confidence values were 0.98, 0.96, and 0.90.valkey-github-issue-4276: luna_a, luna_b, and terra_advisory all abstained with no power edges because the RFC body was truncated inside the governance-model section and lacked implementation evidence; confidence values were 0.90, 0.72, and 0.88.valkey-github-pr-1788: luna_a classified visible license-header standardization as control_event/license with no power edges; luna_b and terra_advisory abstained because truncated patches left uncertainty over whether substantive licensing rights changed. Confidence values were 0.91, 0.55, and 0.38.valkey-io/valkey-samples; calls for community-first governance, inclusive decision-making, quality, vendor neutrality, community review, CI-tested runnable examples, and rejection of uncited performance claims, cost comparisons, and promotional language; specifies CONTRIBUTING.md for quality/review/structure rules and MAINTAINERS.md for maintainers and responsibilities; and truncates after “The repository has its own MAINTAINERS.md following the same model as other valkey-io repositorie”.completed, high, including “Compute supplementary-source SHA-256 values and produce evidence-specific adjudications” (previously in_progress).19:30:02Z; every PR metadata projection matched frozen values, and every base, head, and merge commit resolved. meta_sha hashes sorted compact metadata projections, while diff_sha hashes raw SHA-bound .diff content; recommendations compared frozen responses directly with source evidence rather than model summaries.opentofu-github-pr-2830, assistant verified base 6f0d3d3a07a49309b30960d57225c9f7c701e9a9, head da4ac00ca09d1d9e06e47efd77523a235d49f10c, merge 59d24390b712b87954ee175c38912e56d8f5d974, merged 2025-05-23T12:18:56Z, and meta_sha=26d616d13354d41eced46b78729d0688b19de9242d8841f6d2be62bce0b048cc.S2830-DIFF is the complete 43/43-file SHA-bound diff from base 6f0d3d3a07a49309b30960d57225c9f7c701e9a9 to head da4ac00ca09d1d9e06e47efd77523a235d49f10c, with diff_sha=d0e29ca19a316f6adba72ff002e4faceb7591565fd0cc09840e200cbc7661a4c. Stable raw anchors are MAINTAINERS.md at sha256=070e1718a6dd91bdb648b3ed6e3917d19dd650bd5bace785f11eefdfdc26b3a6 and contributing/FAQ.md at sha256=8d6c97f2d4f93aa696d3293d092c968964a4c7cf50eb640bfd6c33f066b6b5bc.patch:0 gives the TSC technical oversight (set_strategy); 3. patch:1 requires a two-thirds supermajority to add a TSC member (set_membership); 4. patch:1 permits TSC delegation to project maintainers (delegate); 5. patch:1 retains TSC power to overrule decisions (override); 6. patch:0 gives LF Projects title to Project Trademarks (own); 7. S2830-MAINT gives the TSC a maintainer-nomination vote and S2830-FAQ lets maintainers accept features for development.revise for opentofu-github-pr-2830, with final class effective_institutional_change, kind board_or_steering, and body/patch relation consistent, because no frozen response included the omitted maintainer and feature-decision rights together with the core charter edges.patch:2 for OpenTofu PR #2830 omits 2 added closing lines present in immutable CONTRIBUTING.md despite source_text_truncated=false, demonstrating that GitHub-generated patch text is not a stable completeness guarantee.opentofu-github-pr-2953, assistant verified base 3c170157023ac1290c89567ce432c35aa185099a, head 5f5705b8947cd62834733e6c20635d8d13a616dd, merge 75bf1c2f65ad4baabd51a5e88873f805f5b2a1c7, merged 2025-06-25T17:50:10Z, and meta_sha=38d58881741d69db047590ac25ddb9add78cc7b524f162f1b45d3a4070e0784a.S2953-DIFF is a 43-file SHA-bound diff with diff_sha=e192f59aa0b7e25493a926de2d36e66e1ecd9cc50f2cf2169c999e7270a1fd1c; it contains 4 modified pointer/reference files and 39 removals, and all 30 frozen omissions are deleted TSC notes/agendas.reject for opentofu-github-pr-2953, resolving it as control_event/reorganization, relation consistent, with no power edges: the body says “Updated references and moved governance stuff to a new repo opentofu/org,” and patch:0/patch:1 point to opentofu/org/CHARTER.md and opentofu/org/GOVERNANCE.md, but no source states a changed actor or right.main, so the PR cannot prove exact historical contents in the destination repository; this does not alter the bounded finding that the PR relocates documents without stating a rights change.terraform-github-pr-33661, assistant verified base 8a085b427b74ce3829500a59508b77465f1bbef0, head 53c34ff49cfbc1f70d7cdd3dca8040551c53737a, merge 1f011cbaada5bf9cbddadb58ba7c84b223e99467, merged 2023-08-10T22:58:09Z, and meta_sha=7fbdb91a5398f098ca7cc74f155da070c2ae4001d09d73f43ecd2ff7d9004f78.S33661-DIFF is a complete 1,294/1,294-file SHA-bound diff with diff_sha=18cfaf5a4e4b71c17d446d3f90ea255bdfc0b4aa38bb2e3c04a5334ae5587382; outside LICENSE, all 1,293 changes are exact SPDX swaps from MPL-2.0 to BUSL-1.1, using either // or # comment prefixes.patch:0 terms naming HashiCorp, Inc. as licensor, granting production use subject to a prohibition on hosted or embedded offerings competitive with HashiCorp products, and setting the Change License to MPL 2.0.accept from luna_b for terraform-github-pr-33661 because it correctly codes an effective_institutional_change/license, relation consistent, with HashiCorp’s licensing right modified.terraform-github-pr-34847, assistant verified base ca2be46b0e4db9ab64e649da771d527dcd08c505, head 625b32501cd6f637b82cd6c537033b9c3c6cabf1, merge 84df5562f21ae587bbb7e9b2a1c5ada582d0ba11, merged 2024-03-14T16:58:30Z, and meta_sha=015e9c23e599eb2b0c7bafe73d32b4b61f71c1c79af801c14825fab641ebc88f.S34847-DIFF is a complete 86/86-file SHA-bound diff with diff_sha=e3ee929736f871d58b21e9289228a1a582493874f1f15bfab160d30d3051f821.accept from terra_advisory for terraform-github-pr-34847, yielding control_event/product with no power edges./pulls/34847/files returns patch=null for exactly 7 files—ui_output_mock_test.go, upgrade_state_v1_test.go, upgrade_state_v2_test.go, util.go, util_test.go, version.go, and internal/modsdir/manifest.go; frozen patch:15 is 5,173 characters versus the current API’s 16,673; S34847-DIFF closes the governance question.valkey-github-issue-4276, assistant found that current REST title plus "\n\n" plus body is 17,371 characters; its first 12,000 Unicode characters exactly match frozen body; the missing tail is 5,371 characters; full-content sha256=2625a876797ad965bdb35806999eb258c6e4cc353d3e5d3225b2c4367f35de90; and tail sha256=9d907abb28e512fe0e92889033f77a3d7dd1747dbb43b41a23aab09ac84bee27.S4276-META records REST updated_at=2026-08-10T16:03:48Z before the frozen run, GraphQL lastEditedAt=null, canonical metadata sha256=5dc070df3322cd080a1e00caacd193114bf39174fc1555e86f53734fa55359a7, REST retrieval server time 2026-09-08T19:11:53Z, and ETag W/"75f5abb8b127eac4cab0ccd0cc1e91989c6eca4967d56d0eddbabf5efcdf922d".appoint—“Initial maintainers are appointed by the TSC”; 2. maintainer approve—“A maintainer approves the proposal (or requests changes) before implementation begins”; 3. maintainer merge—“Once approved and CI green, the maintainer merges.” The source remains a proposal, stating “Merge this RFC after community discussion.”revise for valkey-github-issue-4276, coding proposal_only/control_rights for valkey-io/valkey-samples with the 3 proposed appoint, approve, and merge edges; however, a byte-identical V1.2 package must remain abstain because its validator cannot ground new edge references until a versioned envelope admits S4276-FULL.updated_at is not body-specific, and REST also returned Last-Modified: 2026-09-04, so the prefix match, pre-run update time, and lastEditedAt=null support source closure without commit-grade historical proof.valkey-github-pr-1788, assistant verified base 1ad0c4feafb149a6f03627de03f4f810801ab875, head 461b170f84d76594cddef4674733f5f815945dee, merge 089b830479f4984e77e570560f85e37212879740, merged 2025-02-27T18:38:26Z, and meta_sha=142704b214e9db58ff91210f0a60b3c1b5361f31c4961554f011c6fbaae49e0b.S1788-DIFF is a complete 31/31-file SHA-bound diff with diff_sha=89076bc7bdb42a5770c46eac0b2d1a34aafd2c703a6322a76ddfbccfcaca540c; every omitted patch only adds or normalizes Valkey copyright notices and the existing BSD-3-Clause identifier.patch:1’s normalization from SPDX-License-Identifier: BSD 3-Clause to SPDX-License-Identifier: BSD-3-Clause, and patch:0 adding the same SPDX identifier immediately above the existing “BSD 3-Clause License”; no text transfers copyright or changes license terms.revise for valkey-github-pr-1788, with final class control_event, kind license, relation consistent, no power edges, and no residual ambiguity, because a copyright notice records attribution rather than proving transfer of ownership or institutional authority.