Dashboard › institutional-transition-lab › Distillation
cea5a9dd-f7fd-4cd5-be1e-66b511062b37["lore_tm_v1_CYZUGecEql_AGK--pZtOXsPhpHpVCLTs_TliqqI3VPU","lore_tm_v1_rciT0ciW0Wq89SwszPCTQjMXlH9Pc4EnyReGNxT8w2s","lore_tm_v1_o3uRWj_aTxLhkd3SZ4mfTakiqE6dgHSAsE3F4iFcKfs","lore_tm_v1_uJpBx6GrXqJ3Q-JHaRn7PlCu6r8FlE6CdghdJsoQOp4","lore_tm_v1_J3afIWNuTmwIDI2RsOH7jK9s5r5apRFYIJU5mTku0uE"]
/tmp/opencode/adjudication-records-final.json, containing 9 ordered records reviewed by opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-primary: 1. terraform-github-issue-35563, 2. terraform-github-pr-21175, 3. terraform-github-pr-21345, 4. terraform-github-pr-22332, 5. terraform-github-pr-22745, 6. terraform-github-pr-33661, 7. terraform-github-pr-34096, 8. terraform-github-pr-34103, 9. terraform-github-pr-34847, 10. terraform-github-pr-38385.terraform-github-issue-35563: decision reject; rationale says the Azure Container Apps platform-specific crash requests a technical fix but establishes no governance, authority, rights, or institutional-rule change; final coding is record_class=no_event, title Terraform crashes on Azure Container Apps, confidence=0.99, with no event kind, dates, affected scope, or power changes; graph basis luna_a with no edge changes.terraform-github-pr-21175: decision accept, accepted_from=luna_a; the merged provider-development guide added the explicit requirement “All Terraform providers are required to contain a MPL-2.0 open source license.” Final coding: effective_institutional_change, event_kind=license, title MPL-2.0 licensing requirement added for Terraform providers, affected scope Terraform providers, announced 2019-05-01, effective 2019-05-02, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.94; effective added edge has actor Terraform, right_kind=license, target All Terraform providers, scope Terraform provider development. Evidence limitation: the guide establishes the requirement but not enforcement beyond the guide.terraform-github-pr-21345: decision revise; the merged code made accept_license required and enforced EULA acceptance for newer or latest Habitat installations through Terraform. Final coding: effective_institutional_change, event_kind=license, title Terraform Habitat provisioner requires EULA acceptance, affected scope Terraform Habitat provisioner installations, announced 2019-05-17, effective 2019-08-05, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.97; effective added edge has actor Terraform, right_kind=set_terms, target Terraform Habitat provisioner installations, and scope Habitat versions newer than 0.79.0 or latest installed through the Terraform Habitat provisioner. The revision replaces a frozen Chef Software modified-license edge because the implementation supports Terraform provisioner authority instead.terraform-github-pr-22332: decision revise; merged revert of hashicorp/terraform#21345 removed the required accept_license field, validation, acceptance command, and related documentation. Final coding: effective_institutional_change, event_kind=license, title Revert Terraform Habitat provisioner license-acceptance requirement, affected scope Terraform Habitat provisioner license-acceptance enforcement and related provisioner documentation, announced and effective 2019-08-05, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.99; effective removed edge has actor Terraform, right_kind=set_terms, target Terraform Habitat provisioner installations, and scope Habitat versions newer than 0.79.0 or latest installed through the Terraform Habitat provisioner. Graph revision basis is luna_b.terraform-github-pr-22745: decision revise; merged code reinstated required EULA acceptance through Terraform’s Habitat provisioner. Final coding: effective_institutional_change, event_kind=license, title Terraform Habitat provisioner reinstates EULA acceptance requirement, affected scope Terraform Habitat provisioner installations, announced and effective 2019-09-09, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.98; effective added edge has actor Terraform, right_kind=set_terms, target Terraform Habitat provisioner installations, and scope Habitat versions newer than 0.79.0 or latest installed through the Terraform Habitat provisioner. The revision removes a frozen edge that incorrectly modeled users as the authority.terraform-github-pr-33661: decision accept, accepted_from=luna_b; merged LICENSE replacement changed Terraform from MPL 2.0 to Business Source License 1.1. Final coding: effective_institutional_change, event_kind=license, title Terraform license changed from MPL 2.0 to Business Source License 1.1, affected scope Terraform Licensed Work, announced and effective 2023-08-10, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.98; effective modified edge has actor/licensor HashiCorp, Inc., right_kind=license, target you, scope The Licensed Work, with Change License: MPL 2.0. Evidence limitation: 1,294 changed files were listed but only 20 patches were frozen; the complete LICENSE replacement directly establishes the license change without supporting claims about every file.terraform-github-pr-34096: decision reject; merged HCL v2.19.0 update is a product/control event rather than an institutional change. Final coding: record_class=control_event, event_kind=product, title Update HCL to v2.19.0, affected scope Terraform's HCL dependency, announced 2023-10-16, effective 2023-10-17, body_patch_relation=not_applicable, confidence=0.99, no power changes; graph basis luna_b. No implementing patch was supplied, so file-level implementation details were not verified.terraform-github-pr-34103: decision reject; merged backport is product maintenance with no governance or authority change. Final coding: record_class=control_event, event_kind=product, title Backport HCL v2.19.0 into v1.6, affected scope Terraform v1.6, announced and effective 2023-10-17, body_patch_relation=body_only, confidence=0.87, no power changes; graph basis terra_advisory. No implementing patch was supplied, so metadata supports completion but not detailed file contents.terraform-github-pr-34847: decision accept, accepted_from=luna_b; responsibility for interpreting historical module-source shorthands moved from go-getter to Terraform, while go-getter retained responsibility for actual module installation. Final coding: effective_institutional_change, event_kind=control_rights, title Terraform takes control of module source address normalization, affected scope Terraform module source address parsing and normalization, announced and effective 2024-03-14, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.96. Two effective set_policy edges cover Interpretation of historical module source address shorthands: removal from actor go-getter and addition to actor Terraform, both targeting Terraform module source address normalization.terraform-github-pr-34847: the complete listing has 86 changed files but the frozen selection has only 16 patches; the body and selected normalization implementation establish the bounded responsibility transfer, not every changed file.terraform-github-pr-38385: decision accept, accepted_from=terra_advisory; the closed, unmerged PR proposed AI-agent commit autonomy but did not implement or adopt it. Final coding: record_class=proposal_only, event_kind=control_rights, title Add AI agent governance, affected scope terraform repository, announced 2026-04-15, no effective date, body_patch_relation=consistent, confidence=0.82; proposed added edge has actor terraform, right_kind=delegate, target AI coding tools (Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Codex, Gemini), and scope autonomous commits in the terraform repository after quality gates pass, based on ## Autonomy and - Auto-commit after gates pass.terraform-github-pr-22332 and terraform-github-pr-22745: files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, source_text_truncated=false. Each has body, pr_metadata, and patches for builtin/provisioners/habitat/resource_provisioner.go, website/docs/provisioners/chef.html.markdown, and website/docs/provisioners/habitat.html.markdown.terraform-github-pr-33661: files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=true, patch_unavailable_count=0, source_text_truncated=false; available sources are body, pr_metadata, and 20 patches ordered as: LICENSE; .github/actions/equivalence-test/action.yml; .github/actions/go-version/action.yml; .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/bug_report.yml; .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/config.yml; .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/documentation_issue.yml; .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/feature_request.yml; .github/scripts/e2e_test_linux_darwin.sh; .github/scripts/equivalence-test.sh; .github/scripts/get_product_version.sh; .github/scripts/verify_docker; .release/ci.hcl; .release/release-metadata.hcl; .release/security-scan.hcl; checkpoint.go; codecov.yml; commands.go; copyright_headers.go; Dockerfile; docs/plugin-protocol/tfplugin5.0.proto.terraform-github-pr-34096 and terraform-github-pr-34103: files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, source_text_truncated=false; only body and pr_metadata sources are present, with no implementing patch source.terraform-github-pr-34847: files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=true, patch_unavailable_count=0, source_text_truncated=false; available sources are body, pr_metadata, and 16 patches ordered as: internal/addrs/module_source.go; internal/configs/configtesting/synth_body.go; internal/configs/configtesting/synth_body_test.go; internal/getmodules/getter.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_abs_filepath.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_gcs.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_gcs_test.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_git.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_git_test.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_remote_shorthands.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_remote_shorthands_test.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_s3.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/detect_s3_test.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/package.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/source_parsing.go; internal/getmodules/moduleaddrs/source_parsing_test.go.terraform-github-pr-38385: files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, patch_unavailable_count=0, source_text_truncated=false; available sources are body, pr_metadata, and 12 patches ordered as: .amazonq/rules/governance.md; .claude/governance.md; .cursor/rules/governance.mdc; .windsurf/rules/governance.md; .changes/v1.16/NOTES-20260415-010000.yaml; .clinerules; .continuerules; .github/copilot-instructions.md; .rules; AGENTS.md; CLAUDE.md; GEMINI.md./home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/documents.json for the Terraform governance records.terraform-github-pr-22332 evidence: publisher hashicorp/terraform, publication date 2019-08-05, source URL https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/22332, and body Revert "Habitat License Acceptance changes. " / Reverts hashicorp/terraform#21345 / Reverting in favor of reviewing #21776.terraform-github-pr-22332 in builtin/provisioners/habitat/resource_provisioner.go: removed the github.com/hashicorp/go-version import; removed AcceptLicense bool; removed required boolean schema field "accept_license"; removed version parsing and validation; removed the 0.79.0 comparison and both errors saying Habitat end user license agreement needs to be accepted, set the accept_license argument to true to accept.terraform-github-pr-22332: website/docs/provisioners/chef.html.markdown removed the requirement to set chef_license to accept in client_options unless installing an old Chef client and removed client_options = ["chef_license 'accept'"]; website/docs/provisioners/habitat.html.markdown removed accept_license = true and removed accept_license (bool) as a required supervisor argument for accepting the Habitat EULA.