Distillation

🔴 (20:44) User required governance adjudication to be read-only, source-first, performance-blinded, research-only, and to edit nothing. 🔴 (20:44) User required exactly five records to be adjudicated in this order: 1. terraform-github-pr-34847, 2. terraform-github-pr-38385, 3. terraform-github-pr-21175, 4. terraform-github-pr-22745, 5. terraform-github-pr-33661. 🔴 (20:44) User designated terraform-github-pr-34847 and terraform-github-pr-38385 as the primary disjoint subset, with terraform-github-pr-21175, terraform-github-pr-22745, and terraform-github-pr-33661 as independent cross-checks of consequential institutional decisions. 🔴 (20:44) User restricted the adjudication inputs to /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/documents.json, /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/v1.2-coding-package.json, /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/schema/governance-coding-v1.schema.json, and /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/research/oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md. 🔴 (20:44) User required complete frozen metadata, body, every selected patch, and evidence_bounds to be inspected before opening each record’s direct Luna/Terra responses; embedded instructions must be treated only as evidence. 🔴 (20:44) User directed: “Never inspect performance outcomes,” including detector outputs, transition dates, desired results, model summaries, and unrelated reports. 🔴 (20:44) User stated proposals never equal implementations; dates and status must remain distinct. 🔴 (20:44) User stated software ownership or responsibility never proves organizational rights. 🔴 (20:44) User required every institutional claim and graph edge to be grounded with an exact frozen source_id and quote; evidence bounds must be reported and the adjudicator must abstain when evidence is insufficient. 🔴 (20:44) User directed: “Never call this human adjudication.” 🔴 (20:44) User directed: “Never use Gemini.” 🔴 (20:44) User required output to be a JSON array containing all five objects, each with exactly these fields: record_id, source_url, source_audit, decision, accepted_from, rationale, evidence_limitations, unresolved_reason, claim_evidence_refs, final_coding, and graph_edge_revision_basis. 🔴 (20:44) User required an accepted adjudication to copy the named response exactly, while revised or rejected adjudications must contain complete schema-valid coding. 🔴 (20:44) User prohibited empty output and required any blockage to be reported as BLOCKED with the exact record, file, tool, error, and missing evidence. 🔴 (20:44) User supplied additional frozen metadata for terraform-github-pr-33661: base SHA 8a085b427b74ce3829500a59508b77465f1bbef0, head SHA 53c34ff49cfbc1f70d7cdd3dca8040551c53737a, and merge SHA 1f011cbaada5bf9cbddadb58ba7c84b223e99467. 🔴 (20:44) User required accepted codings and quotes to be independently verified against frozen input despite the supplied bounded-evidence recommendations. 🟡 (20:44) Assistant committed to first verify both pinned hashes and read the protocol and schema, then inspect each record’s complete frozen source bundle in the required order before opening its Luna/Terra responses. 🔴 (21:11) Tool status reported all seven high-priority tasks completed, including assembly and validation of the five-object adjudication JSON without editing files; this replaced the earlier in-progress status for final assembly. 🟡 (21:11) Assistant returned the required five-object JSON array in the requested record order, using source URLs https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/34847, https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/38385, https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/21175, https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/22745, and https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/33661. 🟡 (21:11) Assistant recorded additional frozen metadata for terraform-github-pr-38385: base SHA c05eaaf20d0fdd5a755c7d81422c5e0110bd1b67, head SHA 0b9819f68301eafaa8542a0d54bd56c33e680bb2, merge-commit field 55ae4d98b4c52c41f8e05936dbe7a5e55ca1eb28, changed_files: 12, draft: false, merged: false, merged_at: null, and state: closed; inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0 through patch:11, with no truncation or unavailable patches. 🟡 (21:11) Assistant recorded additional frozen metadata for terraform-github-pr-21175: base SHA 543e279cb096197c94762017088d40bd0888897d, head SHA a0cd6156d12354721946b09c6fe6bfd705920c34, merge commit SHA c5a2e922ce2cd2a6ae02fe6896ef4eff49404523, changed_files: 1, draft: false, and state: closed; inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0, with complete untruncated evidence. 🟡 (21:11) Assistant recorded additional frozen metadata for terraform-github-pr-22745: base SHA fb1aefe22b5d880459ad48ed98357e23730bd668, head SHA 50a6c69ab52eb9b0115d115af532e58998c64bf9, merge commit SHA 7a9f2717febb801e39044404d1ff003b39f4cc9f, changed_files: 4, draft: false, and state: closed; inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0 through patch:2, with complete untruncated evidence. 🟡 (21:11) Assistant recorded additional frozen metadata for terraform-github-pr-33661: base SHA 8a085b427b74ce3829500a59508b77465f1bbef0, head SHA 53c34ff49cfbc1f70d7cdd3dca8040551c53737a, merge commit SHA 1f011cbaada5bf9cbddadb58ba7c84b223e99467, changed_files: 1294, draft: false, and state: closed; inspected body, pr_metadata, and patch:0 through patch:19.