Distillation

🟡 (20:59) Assistant distinguished the three license cases as: terraform-github-pr-21175, a merged documentation requirement; terraform-github-pr-22745, merged product-side EULA enforcement; and terraform-github-pr-33661, a direct repository-license replacement. Assistant decided to retain grounded rights codings for 22745 and 33661, but revise 21175 by removing its unsupported software-as-rightsholder edge while preserving the effective guide-policy event. 🔴 (21:00) Running python failed with /usr/bin/bash: line 1: python: command not found. 🔴 (21:01) Five final codings validated successfully against governance-coding-v1; every accepted edge quote was an exact substring of the frozen sources. 🔴 (21:04) Tool output reported checksum ded76b6185ef1c965bda4e14cc6bf08dbe98b1cacb648b265a79bb7822754687 -. 🔴 (21:04) Task status changed: verification of pinned artifact hashes/protocol-schema constraints and complete frozen-source/Luna/Terra inspection for terraform-github-pr-34847, terraform-github-pr-38385, terraform-github-pr-21175, terraform-github-pr-22745, and terraform-github-pr-33661 were all completed; assembly and validation of the five-object adjudication JSON without editing files remained in progress. All tasks were high priority. 🔴 (21:08) All 17 adjudicator claim references were validated as exact frozen-source substrings. 🔴 (21:08) The five final source audits verified pinned SHA-256 hashes: documents.json = 2a62ab05687982c112a29f6126227c26c3ff8defc89ca64662753aaf85c3c0ce; v1.2-coding-package.json = 14644759f53071adfe1173d4e25bb01931b8c1591fa8a48295dbd0556a754769. Each audit recorded source_first_before_model_responses: true and every_selected_patch_inspected: true. 🔴 (21:08) Final adjudication for terraform-github-pr-34847 was decision: accept, accepted_from: terra_advisory. Final coding: control_event / product, title “Terraform source-address normalization and dependency pruning,” affected scope “Terraform module source-address parsing and remote backend dependency graph,” confidence 0.9, announced/effective 2024-03-14, consistent body/patch relation, and no power_changes. (meaning Mar 14, 2024) 🔴 (21:08) terraform-github-pr-34847 frozen metadata recorded changed_files: 86, base SHA ca2be46b0e4db9ab64e649da771d527dcd08c505, head SHA 625b32501cd6f637b82cd6c537033b9c3c6cabf1, merge commit SHA 84df5562f21ae587bbb7e9b2a1c5ada582d0ba11, and merged timestamp 2024-03-14T16:58:30Z; inspected sources were body, pr_metadata, and patch:0 through patch:15. (meaning Mar 14, 2024) 🔴 (21:08) terraform-github-pr-34847 had patch_selection_truncated: true, with patch:15 ending mid-hunk, but user-supplied bounded evidence S34847-DIFF closed the classification gap with coverage 86/86 files, diff SHA-256 e3ee929736f871d58b21e9289228a1a582493874f1f15bfab160d30d3051f821, meta SHA-256 015e9c23e599eb2b0c7bafe73d32b4b61f71c1c79af801c14825fab641ebc88f, and bound_status: closed. 🔴 (21:08) User stated the ownership/control wording in terraform-github-pr-34847 describes software responsibility and compatibility behavior, “never organizational authority,” so the bounded coding has no graph edges. 🔴 (21:08) User stated implementation ownership and control language in terraform-github-pr-34847 “never establishes organizational power.” 🔴 (21:08) Final claim evidence for terraform-github-pr-34847 used exact quotes: body, "this doesn't really contain any meaningful changes to the backends"; body, "Terraform is not replacing anything about the actual installation process here; this only affects the interpretation of the few historical shorthand address forms for which the go-getter dependency is considerable overkill."; and pr_metadata, "\"merged\": true, \"merged_at\": \"2024-03-14T16:58:30Z\"". 🔴 (21:08) Final adjudication for terraform-github-pr-38385 was decision: accept, accepted_from: terra_advisory. Final coding remained proposal_only / control_rights, title “Add AI agent governance,” affected scope terraform repository, confidence 0.82, announced 2026-04-15, no effective date, and ambiguity that the closed, unmerged PR proposes but does not implement or establish adoption of AI-agent commit autonomy. (meaning Apr 15, 2026) 🔴 (21:08) Final terraform-github-pr-38385 power change was: actor terraform, status proposed, direction added, right kind delegate, scope “autonomous commits in the terraform repository after quality gates pass,” target “AI coding tools (Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Codex, Gemini).” Exact edge evidence was body "AI coding tools (Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Codex, Gemini)", patch:1 "+## Autonomy\n+- Auto-commit after gates pass", and pr_metadata "\"merged\": false". 🔴 (21:08) Final claim evidence for terraform-github-pr-38385 used body "This PR adds governance configs generated\nfrom your existing CI pipeline — no manual authoring needed.", patch:1 "+## Autonomy\n+- Auto-commit after gates pass", and pr_metadata "\"merged\": false". The proposed delegate edge required no revision because it was grounded in the unmerged policy text and retained change_status: proposed. 🔴 (21:08) Final adjudication for terraform-github-pr-21175 was decision: revise, with no accepted model response. Final coding: effective_institutional_change / license, title “MPL-2.0 licensing requirement added to the Terraform provider development guide,” affected scope “Terraform provider development guide requirements,” confidence 0.94, announced 2019-05-01, effective 2019-05-02, consistent body/patch relation, and no power_changes. (meaning May 2, 2019) 🔴 (21:08) The final terraform-github-pr-21175 rationale removed the candidate license edge because the merged guide requirement does not identify a licensor/licensee, grant or transfer a license, establish ownership, add an organizational right, or demonstrate enforcement beyond the guide. Exact claim evidence was body "Remove unnecessary PR step and add licensing requirement set", patch:0 "All Terraform providers are required to contain a MPL-2.0 open source license.", and pr_metadata "\"merged\": true, \"merged_at\": \"2019-05-02T00:18:05Z\"". 🔴 (21:08) Final adjudication for terraform-github-pr-22745 was decision: accept, accepted_from: terra_advisory. Final coding: effective_institutional_change / license, title “Require Chef EULA acceptance for Habitat provisioning,” affected scope “Terraform Habitat provisioner installations,” confidence 0.95, announced/effective 2019-09-09, and a consistent body/patch relation. (meaning Sep 9, 2019) 🔴 (21:08) User stated: “Going forward Habitat installation will require users to accept Chef EULA.” 🔴 (21:08) User stated the merged Terraform Habitat-provisioner patch “never proves when Chef Software's underlying policy became effective.” 🔴 (21:08) Final terraform-github-pr-22745 power change was: actor users, status effective, direction modified, right kind license, scope “Habitat installation through the Terraform Habitat provisioner,” target “Habitat installation.” The edge is limited to users’ modified licensing relation within Terraform Habitat provisioning and does not assign Chef Software an unproved organizational right or effective date. 🔴 (21:08) Exact final evidence for terraform-github-pr-22745 was body "Going forward Habitat installation will require users to accept Chef EULA.", patch:0 "Habitat end user license agreement needs to be accepted, set the accept_license argument to true to accept", and merged metadata including "\"merged_at\": \"2019-09-09T19:40:20Z\"". (meaning Sep 9, 2019) 🔴 (21:08) Final adjudication for terraform-github-pr-33661 was decision: accept, accepted_from: luna_b. Final coding: effective_institutional_change / license, title “Terraform license changed from MPL 2.0 to Business Source License 1.1,” affected scope “Terraform Licensed Work,” confidence 0.98, announced/effective 2023-08-10, and a consistent body/patch relation. (meaning Aug 10, 2023) 🔴 (21:08) Final terraform-github-pr-33661 power change was: actor HashiCorp, Inc., status effective, direction modified, right kind license, scope “The Licensed Work,” target you. Exact edge evidence was body "This PR was generated as part of recent licensing changes." and patch:0 quotes "Licensor: HashiCorp, Inc.", "Business Source License 1.1", and "Change License: MPL 2.0". 🔴 (21:08) The terraform-github-pr-33661 final rationale found that the merged LICENSE replacement changed Terraform from MPL-2.0 to Business Source License 1.1, named HashiCorp as Licensor, limited production use, retained MPL-2.0 as the Change License, and did not imply ownership transfer. User-supplied bounded evidence S33661-DIFF covered all 1294/1294 files with bound_status: closed, closing repository-wide license/SPDX scope despite patch_selection_truncated: true. 🔴 (21:08) Exact final claim evidence for terraform-github-pr-33661 additionally included pr_metadata "\"merged\": true, \"merged_at\": \"2023-08-10T22:58:09Z\"". (meaning Aug 10, 2023)