Distillation

Date: September 8, 2026

• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied corrected protocol /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/research/oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md, titled “Performance-blinded OSS governance coding protocol v1.2,” frozen 2026-08-27 with status “pre-adjudication evaluator correction; model-informed development protocol.” (meaning Aug 27, 2026)
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied the V1.2 correction rationale: the V1.1 evaluator’s field called “strict edge agreement” compared actor, right, target, direction, and status but omitted edge scope and evidence references; it also failed to route disagreement in the separately coded body/patch relationship, causing 6 records with material differences to be called provisional_exact_agreement.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied the four V1.2 evaluator changes, in order: 1. strict edge signatures include scope and complete grounded evidence references; 2. body/patch-relationship disagreement is an explicit route reason; 3. the remaining non-routed state is renamed provisional_core_agreement; 4. full-response agreement is reported separately and is not required because titles and numeric confidence are not canonical research fields.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied that V1.2 routes 35 records rather than 29, reuses the byte-identical V1.1 coding bundle and both Luna response files from workflow run 33060493337, and repeats only the Terra advisory pass over the corrected route to isolate the evaluator change from model sampling variance.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied that the V1.2 correction occurred before source adjudication or canonical graph construction; no model response, performance observation, transition date, or desired result influenced it; Terra remains advisory; every record remains ineligible for the canonical ledger; and the response schema and frozen envelope are unchanged.
• 🔴 (19:19) User stated: “Going forward Habitat installation will require users to accept Chef EULA.”
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied exact terraform-github-pr-21345 implementation details: required schema field "accept_license" maps to AcceptLicense bool; validation uses version.NewVersion("0.79.0") and rejects a false value for newer or latest Habitat with "Habitat end user license agreement needs to be accepted, set the accept_license argument to true to accept"; accepted installations execute export HAB_LICENSE=accept; hab -V or, with sudo, sudo HAB_LICENSE=accept hab -V.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied that terraform-github-pr-21345 also documented Chef provisioner acceptance via client_options = ["chef_license 'accept'"]; its metadata included changed_files: 4, base_sha: 1c77704a3b2d3140de8002e6a0d5428d442d08b1, head_sha: 258319e6b0d12f7544b97e173bcce04d14d242f3, and merge_commit_sha: 9020636f9330da5f45328a37b9ffe1742d2287a3.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied exact terraform-github-pr-22332 revert mechanics: it removed github.com/hashicorp/go-version, AcceptLicense bool, the required "accept_license" schema field, version/license validation, HAB_LICENSE=accept execution, Chef’s chef_license 'accept' example, and Habitat’s accept_license = true documentation; metadata included changed_files: 4 and merge_commit_sha: da1ab617b82539e239739e9dc79cd6bf896b86c4.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied exact terraform-github-pr-22745 reinstatement mechanics: it restored github.com/hashicorp/go-version, AcceptLicense bool, required "accept_license", the 0.79.0 version threshold, false-value validation, HAB_LICENSE=accept commands, client_options = ["chef_license 'accept'"], and accept_license = true; metadata included changed_files: 4 and merge_commit_sha: 7a9f2717febb801e39044404d1ff003b39f4cc9f.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied additional terraform-github-pr-33661 Business Source License 1.1 terms: licensor HashiCorp, Inc.; copyright (c) 2023 HashiCorp, Inc.; Change Date four years after publication; Change License MPL 2.0; noncompliant use requires purchasing a commercial license or refraining from use; violating use automatically terminates rights for the current and all other versions; SPDX identifiers changed from MPL-2.0 to BUSL-1.1.
• 🔴 (19:19) User supplied terraform-github-pr-33661 metadata: changed_files: 1294, base_sha: 8a085b427b74ce3829500a59508b77465f1bbef0, head_sha: 53c34ff49cfbc1f70d7cdd3dca8040551c53737a, and merge_commit_sha: 1f011cbaada5bf9cbddadb58ba7c84b223e99467.
• 🔴 (19:20) User supplied HCL v2.19.0 details for terraform-github-pr-34096: ext/dynblock’s dynblock.Expand gained an optional hook allowing callers to check and potentially veto particular for_each values by returning error diagnostics, with unchanged behavior when unset; hclsyntax received further fixes for marked values in conditional expressions and improved tracking of refined values into results, building on v2.18.1; the PR fixed issue #34060.
• 🔴 (19:20) User supplied terraform-github-pr-34096 metadata: changed_files: 2, base_sha: 707c426f6892285fc116d68d32559e791a7ab199, head_sha: 1f271185986bcb30eb3e19fcae4457b122f43147, and merge_commit_sha: 493056d828ab0cd17def8e0193f71f4bfe8f9628.
• 🔴 (19:20) User supplied that terraform-github-pr-34103 was auto-generated from #34096 for assessment under label 1.6-backport, listed source commit 1f271185986bcb30eb3e19fcae4457b122f43147, changed 2 files, and had merge_commit_sha: 0c855b0d5e6fe2a9578106f47438fffc4eba3d0e.