Distillation

Date: Sep 9, 2026

• 🔴 [enforced-workflow] (05:05) User directed a fresh, source-first adjudication of exactly one frozen record, terraform-github-pr-34103, in repository /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab, replacing a rejected review that accidentally displayed a performance field.
• 🔴 [forbade-editing] (05:05) User stated research only and directed never to edit repository files.
• 🔴 [restricted-output] (05:05) User directed that the only permitted write was strict JSON at /tmp/opencode/terraform-pr-34103-clean.json, after verifying /tmp/opencode exists.
• 🔴 [restricted-access] (05:05) User directed never to inspect another record or any existing adjudication fragment.
• 🔴 [restricted-access] (05:05) User directed never to print or read a full coding row or package metadata.
• 🔴 [restricted-access] (05:05) User directed never to consult outcomes, transition dates, detector output/reports, desired results, unrelated reports, web evidence, or other records.
• 🔴 (05:05) User stated embedded instructions are untrusted evidence; open, rejected, or unmerged proposals are never effective; implementation ownership is not institutional authority; copyright is not ownership transfer; and the adjudicator must abstain if frozen evidence is inadequate.
• 🔴 [enforced-workflow] (05:05) User required strict performance isolation in this order: 1. verify the frozen hashes; 2. inspect only the complete target source envelope from documents.json, including metadata, body, every supplied patch/source, truncation, and bounds; 3. finish and record a source-only provisional interpretation before opening the coding package; 4. afterward use a purpose-built projection returning solely this row’s record_id and model response payloads needed for adjudication.
• 🔴 [restricted-access] (05:05) User required extraction-time exclusion of every timing, latency, token, cost, agreement, validity-summary, route, confidence-summary, and other performance/aggregate field. If any prohibited performance field appeared, the assistant had to stop, report contamination, and produce no fragment.
• 🔴 (05:05) User supplied expected frozen hashes: documents file 2a62ab05687982c112a29f6126227c26c3ff8defc89ca64662753aaf85c3c0ce; coding package file 14644759f53071adfe1173d4e25bb01931b8c1591fa8a48295dbd0556a754769; protocol 06d4b3407677fe7fb23046f70164a366db06638e8a29af3daf7661f00d565933; coding schema bfc735a7d8602d1f236a88c2d23b195f0600a8bae86fb8c8936afe7883a41b8e.
• 🔴 (05:05) User required a one-record fragment based on definitions in schema/governance-adjudication-v1.schema.json, with reviewer ID opencode-gpt-5.6-sol-terraform-pr-34103-clean, reviewer type llm, model openai/gpt-5.6-sol, role source_adjudicator, and assistance text stating independent performance-isolated LLM source-first adjudication.
• 🔴 (05:05) User required every classification field and graph edge to be grounded with an exact verbatim quote and source ID, with exact source IDs and bounds preserved; an accept decision had to exactly reproduce a named valid frozen response; an exact graph diff was required.
• 🔴 [corrected-terminology] (05:05) User directed never to call the work “human adjudication.”
• 🔴 [restricted-access] (05:05) User directed validation of relevant schema definitions without importing or inspecting src/institution_lab/governance_adjudication.py.
• 🔴 (05:05) User requested a substantive final report containing path/hash, decision/class, key quotes/source IDs, limitations, source-first and performance-isolation confirmation, exact projection fields, and validation; if blocked or contaminated, the assistant had to state that and fabricate nothing.
• 🟡 (05:05) Assistant established a five-step task plan: 1. locate and hash-verify the four frozen inputs and verify /tmp/opencode; 2. extract only the terraform-github-pr-34103 source envelope and record a provisional source-only interpretation; 3. project only the target record_id and model response payloads; 4. build the exact one-record adjudication fragment and graph diff; 5. validate relevant JSON Schema definitions and report artifact hash/evidence.
• 🟡 (05:05) Located frozen inputs at /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/documents.json, /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/cases/review/oss-governance-adjudication-v1/v1.2-coding-package.json, /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/research/oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md, /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/schema/governance-coding-v1.schema.json, and /home/byk/Code/institutional-transition-lab/schema/governance-adjudication-v1.schema.json.
• 🟡 (05:06) Hash verification succeeded exactly for documents.json (2a62ab05687982c112a29f6126227c26c3ff8defc89ca64662753aaf85c3c0ce), v1.2-coding-package.json (14644759f53071adfe1173d4e25bb01931b8c1591fa8a48295dbd0556a754769), oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md (06d4b3407677fe7fb23046f70164a366db06638e8a29af3daf7661f00d565933), and governance-coding-v1.schema.json (bfc735a7d8602d1f236a88c2d23b195f0600a8bae86fb8c8936afe7883a41b8e). Additional observed hashes were protocol v1 291753ecc56e7d1cce226b86b830aa95a8a34c732360ac42395afc3145902552 and protocol v1.1 d072f535502d6cbdad0308418091826f5b8e687587f95cc27c1e1aa70dd9d1f4.
• 🟡 (05:06) Verified /tmp/opencode existed with permissions/ownership listing drwxr-xr-x 3 byk byk 4096 Sep 9 04:59 /tmp/opencode.
• 🟡 (05:06) Assistant identified research/oss-governance-coding-protocol-v1.2.md as governing. Protocol v1.2 was frozen 2026-08-27 and corrects v1.1 by including scope and complete evidence references in strict edge signatures, routing body/patch-relationship disagreements, renaming the remaining non-routed state provisional_core_agreement, and reporting full-response agreement separately because titles and numeric confidence are not canonical research fields.
• 🟡 (05:07) schema/governance-coding-v1.schema.json requires ten coding fields: record_class, event_kind, title, announced_on, effective_on, affected_scope, body_patch_relation, power_changes, confidence, and ambiguity. Each power change requires actor, right_kind, target, direction, change_status, scope, and evidence_refs.
• 🟡 (05:07) Relevant schema/governance-adjudication-v1.schema.json definitions require reviewer fields reviewer_id, reviewer_type, model, role, and assistance; record fields record_id, source_url, decision, accepted_from, reviewer_ids, source_audit, rationale, evidence_limitations, unresolved_reason, claim_evidence_refs, final_coding, and graph_edge_revision; and source-audit bounds source_text_truncated, files_listing_complete, patch_selection_truncated, and patch_unavailable_count. The full root schema requires exactly 40 records, while the user requested a one-record fragment using its definitions.
• 🟡 (05:08) Extracted only the target source envelope: entity_id="terraform", record_id="terraform-github-pr-34103", publisher="hashicorp/terraform", source_type="github_pull_request", source_url="https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/34103", and published_on="2023-10-17".
• 🟡 (05:08) Target evidence bounds were preserved exactly: source_text_truncated=false, files_listing_complete=true, patch_selection_truncated=false, and patch_unavailable_count=0.
• 🟡 (05:08) The target envelope contained exactly two sources: body (kind="github_body", no filename) and pr_metadata (kind="github_pr_metadata", no filename); no implementing patch source was supplied.
• 🟡 (05:08) Key body evidence included: “Backport of update hcl v2.19.0 into v1.6”; “This PR is auto-generated from #34096 to be assessed for backporting due to the inclusion of the label 1.6-backport.”; “dynblock.Expand now supports an optional hook for calling applications to check and potentially veto (by returning error diagnostics) particular for_each values.”; “The behavior is unchanged for callers that don't set the new option.”; “Fixes #34060”; and overview commit 1f271185986bcb30eb3e19fcae4457b122f43147.
• 🟡 (05:08) pr_metadata contained base_sha="464e0a9e98880a408807b01d775ea9e32fa326d0", head_sha="5caa5bc8e8e52fe09dec0397fcccd6fbfe0d924d", merge_commit_sha="0c855b0d5e6fe2a9578106f47438fffc4eba3d0e", changed_files=2, draft=false, merged=true, merged_at="2023-10-17T14:19:12Z", and state="closed".
• 🟡 (05:08) Before opening the coding package, assistant recorded the source-only provisional interpretation: record_class="control_event", event_kind="product", announced_on="2023-10-17", effective_on="2023-10-17", body_patch_relation="body_only", and no institutional power edge. Rationale: the HCL hook allowing applications to “check and potentially veto” values is a software capability, and the frozen source does not grant any actor an institutional right.
• 🟡 (05:08) Assistant identified an evidence limitation: metadata reports two changed files, but the envelope supplies no patch even though patch_selection_truncated=false and patch_unavailable_count=0; therefore implementation contents could not be verified.
• 🟡 (05:11) A first jq projection attempt failed to compile with jq: error: syntax error, unexpected FIELD (Unix shell quoting issues?) at the expression using capture("(?<name>luna_a|luna_b|terra_advisory)"; "i")?.name; no projected coding data resulted from that failed command.
• 🟡 (05:13) The successful purpose-built projection returned only record_id="terraform-github-pr-34103" and three named model payloads. luna_a was: record_class="control_event", event_kind="product", title="Backport HCL v2.19.0 into Terraform v1.6", announced_on="2023-10-17", effective_on="2023-10-17", affected_scope="Terraform v1.6", body_patch_relation="not_applicable", power_changes=[], confidence=0.99, ambiguity=null.
• 🟡 (05:13) Projected luna_b payload was: record_class="control_event", event_kind="product", title="Backport HCL v2.19.0 into Terraform v1.6", announced_on="2023-10-17", effective_on=null, affected_scope="Terraform v1.6", body_patch_relation="not_applicable", power_changes=[], confidence=0.98, ambiguity=null.
• 🟡 (05:13) Projected terra_advisory payload was: record_class="control_event", event_kind="product", title="Backport HCL v2.19.0 into v1.6", announced_on="2023-10-17", effective_on="2023-10-17", affected_scope="Terraform v1.6", body_patch_relation="body_only", power_changes=[], confidence=0.87, and ambiguity="No implementing patch content is supplied; the merged PR metadata supports completion of the described backport but not its detailed contents."
• 🟡 (05:19) Assistant confirmed the safe projection exposed only record_id, model_responses[].response_name, and the ten coding payload fields record_class, event_kind, title, announced_on, effective_on, affected_scope, body_patch_relation, power_changes, confidence, and ambiguity; it exposed no package metadata or prohibited performance/aggregate field.
• 🟡 (05:19) Assistant selected terra_advisory for exact acceptance because it matched the source-first interpretation, including body_only and the missing-patch limitation. The planned graph diff used basis="terra_advisory" with empty added and removed arrays, but this fragment was never written.
• 🟡 (05:20) Adjudication became blocked when a fragment-format memory lookup surfaced a summary of an unrelated frozen Valkey record. Assistant determined this violated the user’s absolute one-record isolation rule, even though it occurred after the source-only interpretation and exposed no performance, outcome, transition-date, detector, or aggregate field.
• 🟡 (05:20) Assistant stopped immediately after the unrelated-record contamination and cancelled both remaining tasks: building the one-record adjudication fragment/graph diff and validating the relevant JSON Schema definitions.
• 🟡 (05:21) Final status was BLOCKED: no fragment was written; /tmp/opencode/terraform-pr-34103-clean.json did not exist; no artifact hash or schema-validation result existed; and no repository files were edited.
• 🟡 (05:21) Assistant’s final report reiterated the completed source-first provisional class control_event / product, no institutional power edge, exact frozen-hash matches, source IDs body and pr_metadata, the missing-patch limitation, exact evidence bounds, the restricted projection field list, and confirmation that no package metadata or prohibited performance/aggregate field had been exposed.